diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'lib/ssh')
-rw-r--r-- | lib/ssh/doc/src/ssh_app.xml | 70 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/ssh/src/ssh.hrl | 1 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/ssh/src/ssh_connection_handler.erl | 129 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/ssh/src/ssh_transport.erl | 494 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/ssh/test/ssh_renegotiate_SUITE.erl | 22 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/ssh/test/ssh_test_lib.erl | 10 |
6 files changed, 475 insertions, 251 deletions
diff --git a/lib/ssh/doc/src/ssh_app.xml b/lib/ssh/doc/src/ssh_app.xml index 29cbbd79a2..79dd1e210e 100644 --- a/lib/ssh/doc/src/ssh_app.xml +++ b/lib/ssh/doc/src/ssh_app.xml @@ -137,6 +137,19 @@ <p>Supported algorithms are:</p> <taglist> + <tag>Key exchange algorithms</tag> + <item> + <list type="bulleted"> + <item>ecdh-sha2-nistp256</item> + <item>ecdh-sha2-nistp384</item> + <item>ecdh-sha2-nistp521</item> + <item>diffie-hellman-group-exchange-sha1</item> + <item>diffie-hellman-group-exchange-sha256</item> + <item>diffie-hellman-group14-sha1</item> + <item>diffie-hellman-group1-sha1</item> + </list> + </item> + <tag>Public key algorithms</tag> <item> <list type="bulleted"> @@ -157,30 +170,26 @@ </list> </item> - <tag>Encryption algorithms</tag> + <tag>Encryption algorithms (ciphers)</tag> <item> <list type="bulleted"> + <item>[email protected] (AEAD_AES_128_GCM)</item> + <item>[email protected] (AEAD_AES_256_GCM)</item> <item>aes128-ctr</item> <item>aes192-ctr</item> <item>aes256-ctr</item> <item>aes128-cbc</item> <item>3des-cbc</item> </list> + <p>Following the internet de-facto standard, the cipher and mac algorithm AEAD_AES_128_GCM is selected when the + cipher [email protected] is negotiated. The cipher and mac algorithm AEAD_AES_256_GCM is selected when the + cipher [email protected] is negotiated. + </p> + <p>See the text at the description of <seealso marker="#rfc5647_note">the rfc 5647 further down</seealso> + for more information. + </p> </item> - - <tag>Key exchange algorithms</tag> - <item> - <list type="bulleted"> - <item>ecdh-sha2-nistp256</item> - <item>ecdh-sha2-nistp384</item> - <item>ecdh-sha2-nistp521</item> - <item>diffie-hellman-group-exchange-sha1</item> - <item>diffie-hellman-group-exchange-sha256</item> - <item>diffie-hellman-group14-sha1</item> - <item>diffie-hellman-group1-sha1</item> - </list> - </item> - + <tag>Compression algorithms</tag> <item> <list type="bulleted"> @@ -255,6 +264,30 @@ <p></p> </item> + <item><url href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5647">RFC 5647</url>, AES Galois Counter Mode for + the Secure Shell Transport Layer Protocol. + <p><marker id="rfc5647_note"/>There is an ambiguity in the synchronized selection of cipher and mac algorithm. + This is resolved by OpenSSH in the ciphers [email protected] and [email protected] which are implemented. + If the explicit ciphers and macs AEAD_AES_128_GCM or AEAD_AES_256_GCM are needed, + they could be enabled with the option preferred_algorithms. + <warning> + If the client or the server is not Erlang/OTP, it is the users responsibility to check that + other implementation has the same interpretation of AEAD_AES_*_GCM as the Erlang/OTP SSH before + enabling them. The aes*[email protected] variants are always safe to use since they lack the + ambiguity. + </warning> + </p> + <p>The second paragraph in section 5.1 is resolved as: + <list type="ordered"> + <item>If the negotiated cipher is AEAD_AES_128_GCM, the mac algorithm is set to AEAD_AES_128_GCM.</item> + <item>If the negotiated cipher is AEAD_AES_256_GCM, the mac algorithm is set to AEAD_AES_256_GCM.</item> + <item>If the mac algorithm is AEAD_AES_128_GCM, the cipher is set to AEAD_AES_128_GCM.</item> + <item>If the mac algorithm is AEAD_AES_256_GCM, the cipher is set to AEAD_AES_256_GCM.</item> + </list> + The first rule that matches when read in order from the top is applied + </p> + </item> + <item><url href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5656">RFC 5656</url>, Elliptic Curve Algorithm Integration in the Secure Shell Transport Layer. <p>Except @@ -266,6 +299,13 @@ </list> </p> </item> + + <item><url href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6668">RFC 6668</url>, SHA-2 Data Integrity Verification for + the Secure Shell (SSH) Transport Layer Protocol + <p>Comment: Defines hmac-sha2-256 and hmac-sha2-512 + </p> + </item> + </list> </section> diff --git a/lib/ssh/src/ssh.hrl b/lib/ssh/src/ssh.hrl index 4ad936f742..8efc743b67 100644 --- a/lib/ssh/src/ssh.hrl +++ b/lib/ssh/src/ssh.hrl @@ -29,7 +29,6 @@ -define(SSH_DEFAULT_PORT, 22). -define(SSH_MAX_PACKET_SIZE, (256*1024)). --define(SSH_LENGHT_INDICATOR_SIZE, 4). -define(REKEY_TIMOUT, 3600000). -define(REKEY_DATA_TIMOUT, 60000). -define(DEFAULT_PROFILE, default). diff --git a/lib/ssh/src/ssh_connection_handler.erl b/lib/ssh/src/ssh_connection_handler.erl index 8448218d91..505c6eb181 100644 --- a/lib/ssh/src/ssh_connection_handler.erl +++ b/lib/ssh/src/ssh_connection_handler.erl @@ -970,57 +970,39 @@ handle_info({Protocol, Socket, Info}, hello, transport_protocol = Protocol} = State) -> event({info_line, Info}, hello, State); -handle_info({Protocol, Socket, Data}, Statename, +handle_info({Protocol, Socket, Data}, StateName, #state{socket = Socket, transport_protocol = Protocol, - ssh_params = #ssh{decrypt_block_size = BlockSize, - recv_mac_size = MacSize} = Ssh0, - decoded_data_buffer = <<>>, - encoded_data_buffer = EncData0} = State0) -> - - %% Implementations SHOULD decrypt the length after receiving the - %% first 8 (or cipher block size, whichever is larger) bytes of a - %% packet. (RFC 4253: Section 6 - Binary Packet Protocol) - case size(EncData0) + size(Data) >= erlang:max(8, BlockSize) of - true -> - {Ssh, SshPacketLen, DecData, EncData} = - - ssh_transport:decrypt_first_block(<<EncData0/binary, - Data/binary>>, Ssh0), - case SshPacketLen > ?SSH_MAX_PACKET_SIZE of - true -> - DisconnectMsg = - #ssh_msg_disconnect{code = - ?SSH_DISCONNECT_PROTOCOL_ERROR, - description = "Bad packet length " - ++ integer_to_list(SshPacketLen), - language = "en"}, - handle_disconnect(DisconnectMsg, State0); - false -> - RemainingSshPacketLen = - (SshPacketLen + ?SSH_LENGHT_INDICATOR_SIZE) - - BlockSize + MacSize, - State = State0#state{ssh_params = Ssh}, - handle_ssh_packet_data(RemainingSshPacketLen, - DecData, EncData, Statename, - State) - end; - false -> - {next_state, Statename, - next_packet(State0#state{encoded_data_buffer = - <<EncData0/binary, Data/binary>>})} + ssh_params = Ssh0, + decoded_data_buffer = DecData0, + encoded_data_buffer = EncData0, + undecoded_packet_length = RemainingSshPacketLen0} = State0) -> + Encoded = <<EncData0/binary, Data/binary>>, + case ssh_transport:handle_packet_part(DecData0, Encoded, RemainingSshPacketLen0, Ssh0) of + {get_more, DecBytes, EncDataRest, RemainingSshPacketLen, Ssh1} -> + {next_state, StateName, + next_packet(State0#state{encoded_data_buffer = EncDataRest, + decoded_data_buffer = DecBytes, + undecoded_packet_length = RemainingSshPacketLen, + ssh_params = Ssh1})}; + {decoded, MsgBytes, EncDataRest, Ssh1} -> + generate_event(MsgBytes, StateName, + State0#state{ssh_params = Ssh1, + %% Important to be set for + %% next_packet +%%% FIXME: the following three seem to always be set in generate_event! + decoded_data_buffer = <<>>, + undecoded_packet_length = undefined, + encoded_data_buffer = EncDataRest}, + EncDataRest); + {bad_mac, Ssh1} -> + DisconnectMsg = + #ssh_msg_disconnect{code = ?SSH_DISCONNECT_PROTOCOL_ERROR, + description = "Bad mac", + language = ""}, + handle_disconnect(DisconnectMsg, State0#state{ssh_params=Ssh1}) end; - -handle_info({Protocol, Socket, Data}, Statename, - #state{socket = Socket, - transport_protocol = Protocol, - decoded_data_buffer = DecData, - encoded_data_buffer = EncData, - undecoded_packet_length = Len} = - State) when is_integer(Len) -> - handle_ssh_packet_data(Len, DecData, <<EncData/binary, Data/binary>>, - Statename, State); - + handle_info({CloseTag, _Socket}, _StateName, #state{transport_close_tag = CloseTag, ssh_params = #ssh{role = _Role, opts = _Opts}} = State) -> @@ -1631,57 +1613,6 @@ after_new_keys_events({connection_reply, _Data} = Reply, {StateName, State}) -> NewState = send_replies([Reply], State), {next_state, StateName, NewState}. -handle_ssh_packet_data(RemainingSshPacketLen, DecData, EncData, StateName, - State) -> - EncSize = size(EncData), - case RemainingSshPacketLen > EncSize of - true -> - {next_state, StateName, - next_packet(State#state{decoded_data_buffer = DecData, - encoded_data_buffer = EncData, - undecoded_packet_length = - RemainingSshPacketLen})}; - false -> - handle_ssh_packet(RemainingSshPacketLen, StateName, - State#state{decoded_data_buffer = DecData, - encoded_data_buffer = EncData}) - - end. - -handle_ssh_packet(Length, StateName, #state{decoded_data_buffer = DecData0, - encoded_data_buffer = EncData0, - ssh_params = Ssh0, - transport_protocol = _Protocol, - socket = _Socket} = State0) -> - try - {Ssh1, DecData, EncData, Mac} = - ssh_transport:unpack(EncData0, Length, Ssh0), - SshPacket = <<DecData0/binary, DecData/binary>>, - case ssh_transport:is_valid_mac(Mac, SshPacket, Ssh1) of - true -> - PacketData = ssh_transport:msg_data(SshPacket), - {Ssh1, Msg} = ssh_transport:decompress(Ssh1, PacketData), - generate_event(Msg, StateName, - State0#state{ssh_params = Ssh1, - %% Important to be set for - %% next_packet - decoded_data_buffer = <<>>}, - EncData); - false -> - DisconnectMsg = - #ssh_msg_disconnect{code = ?SSH_DISCONNECT_PROTOCOL_ERROR, - description = "Bad mac", - language = "en"}, - handle_disconnect(DisconnectMsg, State0) - end - catch _:_ -> - Disconnect = - #ssh_msg_disconnect{code = ?SSH_DISCONNECT_PROTOCOL_ERROR, - description = "Bad input", - language = "en"}, - handle_disconnect(Disconnect, State0) - end. - handle_disconnect(DisconnectMsg, State) -> handle_disconnect(own, DisconnectMsg, State). diff --git a/lib/ssh/src/ssh_transport.erl b/lib/ssh/src/ssh_transport.erl index 0c999b96cc..041e86bae1 100644 --- a/lib/ssh/src/ssh_transport.erl +++ b/lib/ssh/src/ssh_transport.erl @@ -31,10 +31,10 @@ -include("ssh.hrl"). -export([versions/2, hello_version_msg/1]). --export([next_seqnum/1, decrypt_first_block/2, decrypt_blocks/3, +-export([next_seqnum/1, supported_algorithms/0, supported_algorithms/1, default_algorithms/0, default_algorithms/1, - is_valid_mac/3, + handle_packet_part/4, handle_hello_version/1, key_exchange_init_msg/1, key_init/3, new_keys_message/1, @@ -45,9 +45,13 @@ handle_kex_ecdh_init/2, handle_kex_ecdh_reply/2, extract_public_key/1, - unpack/3, decompress/2, ssh_packet/2, pack/2, pack/3, msg_data/1, + ssh_packet/2, pack/2, sign/3, verify/4]). +%%% For test suites +-export([pack/3]). +-export([decompress/2, decrypt_blocks/3, is_valid_mac/3 ]). % FIXME: remove + %%%---------------------------------------------------------------------------- %%% %%% There is a difference between supported and default algorithms. The @@ -66,10 +70,15 @@ default_algorithms() -> [{K,default_algorithms(K)} || K <- algo_classes()]. algo_classes() -> [kex, public_key, cipher, mac, compression]. -%% default_algorithms(kex) -> % Example of how to disable an algorithm -%% supported_algorithms(kex, ['ecdh-sha2-nistp521']); + +default_algorithms(cipher) -> + supported_algorithms(cipher, same(['AEAD_AES_128_GCM', + 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM'])); +default_algorithms(mac) -> + supported_algorithms(mac, same(['AEAD_AES_128_GCM', + 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM'])); default_algorithms(Alg) -> - supported_algorithms(Alg). + supported_algorithms(Alg, []). supported_algorithms() -> [{K,supported_algorithms(K)} || K <- algo_classes()]. @@ -97,19 +106,25 @@ supported_algorithms(public_key) -> supported_algorithms(cipher) -> same( select_crypto_supported( - [{'aes256-ctr', [{ciphers,{aes_ctr,256}}]}, - {'aes192-ctr', [{ciphers,{aes_ctr,192}}]}, - {'aes128-ctr', [{ciphers,{aes_ctr,128}}]}, - {'aes128-cbc', [{ciphers,aes_cbc128}]}, - {'3des-cbc', [{ciphers,des3_cbc}]} + [{'aes256-ctr', [{ciphers,{aes_ctr,256}}]}, + {'aes192-ctr', [{ciphers,{aes_ctr,192}}]}, + {'aes128-ctr', [{ciphers,{aes_ctr,128}}]}, + {'aes128-cbc', [{ciphers,aes_cbc128}]}, + {'[email protected]', [{ciphers,{aes_gcm,128}}]}, + {'[email protected]', [{ciphers,{aes_gcm,256}}]}, + {'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', [{ciphers,{aes_gcm,128}}]}, + {'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', [{ciphers,{aes_gcm,256}}]}, + {'3des-cbc', [{ciphers,des3_cbc}]} ] )); supported_algorithms(mac) -> same( select_crypto_supported( - [{'hmac-sha2-256', [{hashs,sha256}]}, - {'hmac-sha2-512', [{hashs,sha512}]}, - {'hmac-sha1', [{hashs,sha}]} + [{'hmac-sha2-256', [{hashs,sha256}]}, + {'hmac-sha2-512', [{hashs,sha512}]}, + {'hmac-sha1', [{hashs,sha}]}, + {'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', [{ciphers,{aes_gcm,128}}]}, + {'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', [{ciphers,{aes_gcm,256}}]} ] )); supported_algorithms(compression) -> @@ -118,46 +133,6 @@ supported_algorithms(compression) -> 'zlib' ]). -%% Dialyzer complains when not called...supported_algorithms(Key, [{client2server,BL1},{server2client,BL2}]) -> -%% Dialyzer complains when not called... [{client2server,As1},{server2client,As2}] = supported_algorithms(Key), -%% Dialyzer complains when not called... [{client2server,As1--BL1},{server2client,As2--BL2}]; -%% Dialyzer complains when not called...supported_algorithms(Key, BlackList) -> -%% Dialyzer complains when not called... supported_algorithms(Key) -- BlackList. - -select_crypto_supported(L) -> - Sup = [{ec_curve,crypto_supported_curves()} | crypto:supports()], - [Name || {Name,CryptoRequires} <- L, - crypto_supported(CryptoRequires, Sup)]. - -crypto_supported_curves() -> - try crypto:ec_curves() - catch _:_ -> [] - end. - -crypto_supported(Conditions, Supported) -> - lists:all( fun({Tag,CryptoName}) when is_atom(CryptoName) -> - crypto_name_supported(Tag,CryptoName,Supported); - ({Tag,{Name=aes_ctr,Len}}) when is_integer(Len) -> - crypto_name_supported(Tag,Name,Supported) andalso - ctr_len_supported(Name,Len) - end, Conditions). - -crypto_name_supported(Tag, CryptoName, Supported) -> - lists:member(CryptoName, proplists:get_value(Tag,Supported,[])). - -ctr_len_supported(Name, Len) -> - try - crypto:stream_encrypt(crypto:stream_init(Name, <<0:Len>>, <<0:128>>), <<"">>) - of - {_,X} -> is_binary(X) - catch - _:_ -> false - end. - - -same(Algs) -> [{client2server,Algs}, {server2client,Algs}]. - - %%%---------------------------------------------------------------------------- versions(client, Options)-> Vsn = proplists:get_value(vsn, Options, ?DEFAULT_CLIENT_VERSION), @@ -196,12 +171,6 @@ hello_version_msg(Data) -> next_seqnum(SeqNum) -> (SeqNum + 1) band 16#ffffffff. -decrypt_first_block(Bin, #ssh{decrypt_block_size = BlockSize} = Ssh0) -> - <<EncBlock:BlockSize/binary, EncData/binary>> = Bin, - {Ssh, <<?UINT32(PacketLen), _/binary>> = DecData} = - decrypt(Ssh0, EncBlock), - {Ssh, PacketLen, DecData, EncData}. - decrypt_blocks(Bin, Length, Ssh0) -> <<EncBlocks:Length/binary, EncData/binary>> = Bin, {Ssh, DecData} = decrypt(Ssh0, EncBlocks), @@ -757,8 +726,12 @@ known_host_key(#ssh{opts = Opts, key_cb = Mod, peer = Peer} = Ssh, %% The first algorithm in each list MUST be the preferred (guessed) %% algorithm. Each string MUST contain at least one algorithm name. select_algorithm(Role, Client, Server) -> - {Encrypt, Decrypt} = select_encrypt_decrypt(Role, Client, Server), - {SendMac, RecvMac} = select_send_recv_mac(Role, Client, Server), + {Encrypt0, Decrypt0} = select_encrypt_decrypt(Role, Client, Server), + {SendMac0, RecvMac0} = select_send_recv_mac(Role, Client, Server), + + {Encrypt, SendMac} = aead_gcm_simultan(Encrypt0, SendMac0), + {Decrypt, RecvMac} = aead_gcm_simultan(Decrypt0, RecvMac0), + {Compression, Decompression} = select_compression_decompression(Role, Client, Server), @@ -789,6 +762,38 @@ select_algorithm(Role, Client, Server) -> s_lng = S_Lng}, {ok, Alg}. + +%%% It is an agreed problem with RFC 5674 that if the selection is +%%% Cipher = AEAD_AES_x_GCM and +%%% Mac = AEAD_AES_y_GCM (where x =/= y) +%%% then it is undefined what length should be selected. +%%% +%%% If only one of the two lengths (128,256) is available, I claim that +%%% there is no such ambiguity. + +%%% From https://anongit.mindrot.org/openssh.git/plain/PROTOCOL +%%% (read Nov 20, 2015) +%%% 1.6 transport: AES-GCM +%%% +%%% OpenSSH supports the AES-GCM algorithm as specified in RFC 5647. +%%% Because of problems with the specification of the key exchange +%%% the behaviour of OpenSSH differs from the RFC as follows: +%%% +%%% AES-GCM is only negotiated as the cipher algorithms +%%% "[email protected]" or "[email protected]" and never as +%%% an MAC algorithm. Additionally, if AES-GCM is selected as the cipher +%%% the exchanged MAC algorithms are ignored and there doesn't have to be +%%% a matching MAC. + +aead_gcm_simultan('[email protected]', _) -> {'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM'}; +aead_gcm_simultan('[email protected]', _) -> {'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM'}; +aead_gcm_simultan('AEAD_AES_128_GCM', _) -> {'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM'}; +aead_gcm_simultan('AEAD_AES_256_GCM', _) -> {'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM'}; +aead_gcm_simultan(_, 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM') -> {'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM'}; +aead_gcm_simultan(_, 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM') -> {'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM'}; +aead_gcm_simultan(Cipher, Mac) -> {Cipher,Mac}. + + select_encrypt_decrypt(client, Client, Server) -> Encrypt = select(Client#ssh_msg_kexinit.encryption_algorithms_client_to_server, @@ -823,18 +828,18 @@ select_compression_decompression(client, Client, Server) -> Compression = select(Client#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_client_to_server, Server#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_client_to_server), - Decomprssion = + Decompression = select(Client#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_server_to_client, Server#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_server_to_client), - {Compression, Decomprssion}; + {Compression, Decompression}; select_compression_decompression(server, Client, Server) -> - Decomprssion = + Decompression = select(Client#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_client_to_server, Server#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_client_to_server), Compression = select(Client#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_server_to_client, Server#ssh_msg_kexinit.compression_algorithms_server_to_client), - {Compression, Decomprssion}. + {Compression, Decompression}. install_alg(SSH) -> SSH1 = alg_final(SSH), @@ -911,14 +916,39 @@ pack(Data, Ssh=#ssh{}) -> %%% Note: pack/3 is only to be called from tests that wants %%% to deliberetly send packets with wrong PacketLength! %%% Use pack/2 for all other purposes! -pack(Data0, #ssh{encrypt_block_size = BlockSize, - send_sequence = SeqNum, send_mac = MacAlg, - send_mac_key = MacKey, - random_length_padding = RandomLengthPadding} - = Ssh0, - PacketLenDeviationForTests) when is_binary(Data0) -> - {Ssh1, Data} = compress(Ssh0, Data0), - PL = (BlockSize - ((4 + 1 + size(Data)) rem BlockSize)) rem BlockSize, +pack(PlainText, + #ssh{send_sequence = SeqNum, + send_mac = MacAlg, + send_mac_key = MacKey, + encrypt = CryptoAlg} = Ssh0, PacketLenDeviationForTests) when is_binary(PlainText) -> + + {Ssh1, CompressedPlainText} = compress(Ssh0, PlainText), + {EcryptedPacket, MAC, Ssh3} = + case pkt_type(CryptoAlg) of + common -> + PaddingLen = padding_length(4+1+size(CompressedPlainText), Ssh0), + Padding = ssh_bits:random(PaddingLen), + PlainPacketLen = 1 + PaddingLen + size(CompressedPlainText) + PacketLenDeviationForTests, + PlainPacketData = <<?UINT32(PlainPacketLen),?BYTE(PaddingLen), CompressedPlainText/binary, Padding/binary>>, + {Ssh2, EcryptedPacket0} = encrypt(Ssh1, PlainPacketData), + MAC0 = mac(MacAlg, MacKey, SeqNum, PlainPacketData), + {EcryptedPacket0, MAC0, Ssh2}; + aead -> + PaddingLen = padding_length(1+size(CompressedPlainText), Ssh0), + Padding = ssh_bits:random(PaddingLen), + PlainPacketLen = 1 + PaddingLen + size(CompressedPlainText) + PacketLenDeviationForTests, + PlainPacketData = <<?BYTE(PaddingLen), CompressedPlainText/binary, Padding/binary>>, + {Ssh2, {EcryptedPacket0,MAC0}} = encrypt(Ssh1, {<<?UINT32(PlainPacketLen)>>,PlainPacketData}), + {<<?UINT32(PlainPacketLen),EcryptedPacket0/binary>>, MAC0, Ssh2} + end, + FinalPacket = [EcryptedPacket, MAC], + Ssh = Ssh3#ssh{send_sequence = (SeqNum+1) band 16#ffffffff}, + {FinalPacket, Ssh}. + + +padding_length(Size, #ssh{encrypt_block_size = BlockSize, + random_length_padding = RandomLengthPadding}) -> + PL = (BlockSize - (Size rem BlockSize)) rem BlockSize, MinPaddingLen = if PL < 4 -> PL + BlockSize; true -> PL end, @@ -927,45 +957,94 @@ pack(Data0, #ssh{encrypt_block_size = BlockSize, ExtraPaddingLen = try crypto:rand_uniform(0,MaxExtraBlocks)*PadBlockSize catch _:_ -> 0 end, - PaddingLen = MinPaddingLen + ExtraPaddingLen, - Padding = ssh_bits:random(PaddingLen), - PacketLen = 1 + PaddingLen + size(Data) + PacketLenDeviationForTests, - PacketData = <<?UINT32(PacketLen),?BYTE(PaddingLen), - Data/binary, Padding/binary>>, - {Ssh2, EncPacket} = encrypt(Ssh1, PacketData), - MAC = mac(MacAlg, MacKey, SeqNum, PacketData), - Packet = [EncPacket, MAC], - Ssh = Ssh2#ssh{send_sequence = (SeqNum+1) band 16#ffffffff}, - {Packet, Ssh}. - -unpack(EncodedSoFar, ReminingLenght, #ssh{recv_mac_size = MacSize} = Ssh0) -> - SshLength = ReminingLenght - MacSize, - {NoMac, Mac, Rest} = case MacSize of - 0 -> - <<NoMac0:SshLength/binary, - Rest0/binary>> = EncodedSoFar, - {NoMac0, <<>>, Rest0}; - _ -> - <<NoMac0:SshLength/binary, - Mac0:MacSize/binary, - Rest0/binary>> = EncodedSoFar, - {NoMac0, Mac0, Rest0} - end, - {Ssh1, DecData, <<>>} = - case SshLength of - 0 -> - {Ssh0, <<>>, <<>>}; - _ -> - decrypt_blocks(NoMac, SshLength, Ssh0) - end, - {Ssh1, DecData, Rest, Mac}. + MinPaddingLen + ExtraPaddingLen. + + + +handle_packet_part(<<>>, Encrypted0, undefined, #ssh{decrypt = CryptoAlg} = Ssh0) -> + %% New ssh packet + case get_length(pkt_type(CryptoAlg), Encrypted0, Ssh0) of + get_more -> + %% too short to get the length + {get_more, <<>>, Encrypted0, undefined, Ssh0}; + + {ok, PacketLen, _, _, _} when PacketLen > ?SSH_MAX_PACKET_SIZE -> + %% far too long message than expected + throw(#ssh_msg_disconnect{code = ?SSH_DISCONNECT_PROTOCOL_ERROR, + description = "Bad packet length " + ++ integer_to_list(PacketLen), + language = ""}); + + {ok, PacketLen, Decrypted, Encrypted1, + #ssh{recv_mac_size = MacSize} = Ssh1} -> + %% enough bytes so we got the length and can calculate how many + %% more bytes to expect for a full packet + TotalNeeded = (4 + PacketLen + MacSize), + handle_packet_part(Decrypted, Encrypted1, TotalNeeded, Ssh1) + end; + +handle_packet_part(DecryptedPfx, EncryptedBuffer, TotalNeeded, Ssh0) + when (size(DecryptedPfx)+size(EncryptedBuffer)) < TotalNeeded -> + %% need more bytes to finalize the packet + {get_more, DecryptedPfx, EncryptedBuffer, TotalNeeded, Ssh0}; + +handle_packet_part(DecryptedPfx, EncryptedBuffer, TotalNeeded, + #ssh{recv_mac_size = MacSize, + decrypt = CryptoAlg} = Ssh0) -> + %% enough bytes to decode the packet. + DecryptLen = TotalNeeded - size(DecryptedPfx) - MacSize, + <<EncryptedSfx:DecryptLen/binary, Mac:MacSize/binary, NextPacketBytes/binary>> = EncryptedBuffer, + case pkt_type(CryptoAlg) of + common -> + {Ssh1, DecryptedSfx} = decrypt(Ssh0, EncryptedSfx), + DecryptedPacket = <<DecryptedPfx/binary, DecryptedSfx/binary>>, + case is_valid_mac(Mac, DecryptedPacket, Ssh1) of + false -> + {bad_mac, Ssh1}; + true -> + {Ssh, DecompressedPayload} = decompress(Ssh1, payload(DecryptedPacket)), + {decoded, DecompressedPayload, NextPacketBytes, Ssh} + end; + aead -> + PacketLenBin = DecryptedPfx, + case decrypt(Ssh0, {PacketLenBin,EncryptedSfx,Mac}) of + {Ssh1, error} -> + {bad_mac, Ssh1}; + {Ssh1, DecryptedSfx} -> + DecryptedPacket = <<DecryptedPfx/binary, DecryptedSfx/binary>>, + {Ssh, DecompressedPayload} = decompress(Ssh1, payload(DecryptedPacket)), + {decoded, DecompressedPayload, NextPacketBytes, Ssh} + end + end. + + +get_length(common, EncryptedBuffer, #ssh{decrypt_block_size = BlockSize} = Ssh0) -> + case size(EncryptedBuffer) >= erlang:max(8, BlockSize) of + true -> + <<EncBlock:BlockSize/binary, EncryptedRest/binary>> = EncryptedBuffer, + {Ssh, + <<?UINT32(PacketLen),_/binary>> = Decrypted} = decrypt(Ssh0, EncBlock), + {ok, PacketLen, Decrypted, EncryptedRest, Ssh}; + false -> + get_more + end; +get_length(aead, EncryptedBuffer, Ssh) -> + case size(EncryptedBuffer) >= 4 of + true -> + <<?UINT32(PacketLen), EncryptedRest/binary>> = EncryptedBuffer, + {ok, PacketLen, <<?UINT32(PacketLen)>>, EncryptedRest, Ssh}; + false -> + get_more + end. + +pkt_type('AEAD_AES_128_GCM') -> aead; +pkt_type('AEAD_AES_256_GCM') -> aead; +pkt_type(_) -> common. -msg_data(PacketData) -> - <<Len:32, PaddingLen:8, _/binary>> = PacketData, - DataLen = Len - PaddingLen - 1, - <<_:32, _:8, Data:DataLen/binary, - _:PaddingLen/binary>> = PacketData, - Data. +payload(<<PacketLen:32, PaddingLen:8, PayloadAndPadding/binary>>) -> + PayloadLen = PacketLen - PaddingLen - 1, + <<Payload:PayloadLen/binary, _/binary>> = PayloadAndPadding, + Payload. sign(SigData, Hash, #'DSAPrivateKey'{} = Key) -> DerSignature = public_key:sign(SigData, Hash, Key), @@ -991,6 +1070,7 @@ verify(PlainText, Hash, Sig, {#'ECPoint'{},_} = Key) -> verify(PlainText, Hash, Sig, Key) -> public_key:verify(PlainText, Hash, Sig, Key). + %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %% %% Encryption @@ -999,6 +1079,30 @@ verify(PlainText, Hash, Sig, Key) -> encrypt_init(#ssh{encrypt = none} = Ssh) -> {ok, Ssh}; +encrypt_init(#ssh{encrypt = 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', role = client} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "A", 12*8), + <<K:16/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "C", 128), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{encrypt_keys = K, + encrypt_block_size = 16, + encrypt_ctx = IV}}; +encrypt_init(#ssh{encrypt = 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', role = server} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "B", 12*8), + <<K:16/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "D", 128), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{encrypt_keys = K, + encrypt_block_size = 16, + encrypt_ctx = IV}}; +encrypt_init(#ssh{encrypt = 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', role = client} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "A", 12*8), + <<K:32/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "C", 256), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{encrypt_keys = K, + encrypt_block_size = 16, + encrypt_ctx = IV}}; +encrypt_init(#ssh{encrypt = 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', role = server} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "B", 12*8), + <<K:32/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "D", 256), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{encrypt_keys = K, + encrypt_block_size = 16, + encrypt_ctx = IV}}; encrypt_init(#ssh{encrypt = '3des-cbc', role = client} = Ssh) -> IV = hash(Ssh, "A", 64), <<K1:8/binary, K2:8/binary, K3:8/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "C", 192), @@ -1075,6 +1179,18 @@ encrypt_final(Ssh) -> encrypt(#ssh{encrypt = none} = Ssh, Data) -> {Ssh, Data}; +encrypt(#ssh{encrypt = 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', + encrypt_keys = K, + encrypt_ctx = IV0} = Ssh, Data={_AAD,_Ptext}) -> + Enc = {_Ctext,_Ctag} = crypto:block_encrypt(aes_gcm, K, IV0, Data), + IV = next_gcm_iv(IV0), + {Ssh#ssh{encrypt_ctx = IV}, Enc}; +encrypt(#ssh{encrypt = 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', + encrypt_keys = K, + encrypt_ctx = IV0} = Ssh, Data={_AAD,_Ptext}) -> + Enc = {_Ctext,_Ctag} = crypto:block_encrypt(aes_gcm, K, IV0, Data), + IV = next_gcm_iv(IV0), + {Ssh#ssh{encrypt_ctx = IV}, Enc}; encrypt(#ssh{encrypt = '3des-cbc', encrypt_keys = {K1,K2,K3}, encrypt_ctx = IV0} = Ssh, Data) -> @@ -1107,6 +1223,30 @@ encrypt(#ssh{encrypt = 'aes256-ctr', decrypt_init(#ssh{decrypt = none} = Ssh) -> {ok, Ssh}; +decrypt_init(#ssh{decrypt = 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', role = client} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "B", 12*8), + <<K:16/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "D", 128), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{decrypt_keys = K, + decrypt_block_size = 16, + decrypt_ctx = IV}}; +decrypt_init(#ssh{decrypt = 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', role = server} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "A", 12*8), + <<K:16/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "C", 128), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{decrypt_keys = K, + decrypt_block_size = 16, + decrypt_ctx = IV}}; +decrypt_init(#ssh{decrypt = 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', role = client} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "B", 12*8), + <<K:32/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "D", 256), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{decrypt_keys = K, + decrypt_block_size = 16, + decrypt_ctx = IV}}; +decrypt_init(#ssh{decrypt = 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', role = server} = Ssh) -> + IV = hash(Ssh, "A", 12*8), + <<K:32/binary>> = hash(Ssh, "C", 256), + {ok, Ssh#ssh{decrypt_keys = K, + decrypt_block_size = 16, + decrypt_ctx = IV}}; decrypt_init(#ssh{decrypt = '3des-cbc', role = client} = Ssh) -> {IV, KD} = {hash(Ssh, "B", 64), hash(Ssh, "D", 192)}, @@ -1181,8 +1321,22 @@ decrypt_final(Ssh) -> decrypt_ctx = undefined, decrypt_block_size = 8}}. +decrypt(Ssh, <<>>) -> + {Ssh, <<>>}; decrypt(#ssh{decrypt = none} = Ssh, Data) -> {Ssh, Data}; +decrypt(#ssh{decrypt = 'AEAD_AES_128_GCM', + decrypt_keys = K, + decrypt_ctx = IV0} = Ssh, Data = {_AAD,_Ctext,_Ctag}) -> + Dec = crypto:block_decrypt(aes_gcm, K, IV0, Data), % Dec = PlainText | error + IV = next_gcm_iv(IV0), + {Ssh#ssh{decrypt_ctx = IV}, Dec}; +decrypt(#ssh{decrypt = 'AEAD_AES_256_GCM', + decrypt_keys = K, + decrypt_ctx = IV0} = Ssh, Data = {_AAD,_Ctext,_Ctag}) -> + Dec = crypto:block_decrypt(aes_gcm, K, IV0, Data), % Dec = PlainText | error + IV = next_gcm_iv(IV0), + {Ssh#ssh{decrypt_ctx = IV}, Dec}; decrypt(#ssh{decrypt = '3des-cbc', decrypt_keys = Keys, decrypt_ctx = IV0} = Ssh, Data) -> {K1, K2, K3} = Keys, @@ -1207,6 +1361,10 @@ decrypt(#ssh{decrypt = 'aes256-ctr', {State, Enc} = crypto:stream_decrypt(State0,Data), {Ssh#ssh{decrypt_ctx = State}, Enc}. + +next_gcm_iv(<<Fixed:32, InvCtr:64>>) -> <<Fixed:32, (InvCtr+1):64>>. + + %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %% Compression %% @@ -1295,28 +1453,42 @@ decompress(#ssh{decompress = '[email protected]', decompress_ctx = Context, authe %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% send_mac_init(SSH) -> - case SSH#ssh.role of - client -> - KeySize =mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.send_mac), - Key = hash(SSH, "E", KeySize), - {ok, SSH#ssh { send_mac_key = Key }}; - server -> - KeySize = mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.send_mac), - Key = hash(SSH, "F", KeySize), - {ok, SSH#ssh { send_mac_key = Key }} + case pkt_type(SSH#ssh.send_mac) of + common -> + case SSH#ssh.role of + client -> + KeySize = mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.send_mac), + Key = hash(SSH, "E", KeySize), + {ok, SSH#ssh { send_mac_key = Key }}; + server -> + KeySize = mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.send_mac), + Key = hash(SSH, "F", KeySize), + {ok, SSH#ssh { send_mac_key = Key }} + end; + aead -> + %% Not applicable + {ok, SSH} end. send_mac_final(SSH) -> - {ok, SSH#ssh { send_mac = none, send_mac_key = undefined }}. + {ok, SSH#ssh {send_mac = none, + send_mac_key = undefined }}. + recv_mac_init(SSH) -> - case SSH#ssh.role of - client -> - Key = hash(SSH, "F", mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.recv_mac)), - {ok, SSH#ssh { recv_mac_key = Key }}; - server -> - Key = hash(SSH, "E", mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.recv_mac)), - {ok, SSH#ssh { recv_mac_key = Key }} + case pkt_type(SSH#ssh.recv_mac) of + common -> + case SSH#ssh.role of + client -> + Key = hash(SSH, "F", mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.recv_mac)), + {ok, SSH#ssh { recv_mac_key = Key }}; + server -> + Key = hash(SSH, "E", mac_key_size(SSH#ssh.recv_mac)), + {ok, SSH#ssh { recv_mac_key = Key }} + end; + aead -> + %% Not applicable + {ok, SSH} end. recv_mac_final(SSH) -> @@ -1447,6 +1619,8 @@ mac_digest_size('hmac-md5') -> 20; mac_digest_size('hmac-md5-96') -> 12; mac_digest_size('hmac-sha2-256') -> 32; mac_digest_size('hmac-sha2-512') -> 64; +mac_digest_size('AEAD_AES_128_GCM') -> 16; +mac_digest_size('AEAD_AES_256_GCM') -> 16; mac_digest_size(none) -> 0. peer_name({Host, _}) -> @@ -1476,6 +1650,68 @@ ecdh_curve('ecdh-sha2-nistp256') -> secp256r1; ecdh_curve('ecdh-sha2-nistp384') -> secp384r1; ecdh_curve('ecdh-sha2-nistp521') -> secp521r1. + +%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% +%% +%% Utils for default_algorithms/1 and supported_algorithms/1 +%% +%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% + +supported_algorithms(Key, [{client2server,BL1},{server2client,BL2}]) -> + [{client2server,As1},{server2client,As2}] = supported_algorithms(Key), + [{client2server,As1--BL1},{server2client,As2--BL2}]; +supported_algorithms(Key, BlackList) -> + supported_algorithms(Key) -- BlackList. + + +select_crypto_supported(L) -> + Sup = [{ec_curve,crypto_supported_curves()} | crypto:supports()], + [Name || {Name,CryptoRequires} <- L, + crypto_supported(CryptoRequires, Sup)]. + +crypto_supported_curves() -> + try crypto:ec_curves() + catch _:_ -> [] + end. + +crypto_supported(Conditions, Supported) -> + lists:all( fun({Tag,CryptoName}) when is_atom(CryptoName) -> + crypto_name_supported(Tag,CryptoName,Supported); + ({Tag,{Name,Len}}) when is_integer(Len) -> + crypto_name_supported(Tag,Name,Supported) andalso + len_supported(Name,Len) + end, Conditions). + +crypto_name_supported(Tag, CryptoName, Supported) -> + lists:member(CryptoName, proplists:get_value(Tag,Supported,[])). + +len_supported(Name, Len) -> + try + case Name of + aes_ctr -> + {_, <<_/binary>>} = + %% Test encryption + crypto:stream_encrypt(crypto:stream_init(Name, <<0:Len>>, <<0:128>>), <<"">>); + aes_gcm -> + {<<_/binary>>, <<_/binary>>} = + crypto:block_encrypt(Name, + _Key = <<0:Len>>, + _IV = <<0:12/unsigned-unit:8>>, + {<<"AAD">>,"PT"}) + end + of + _ -> true + catch + _:_ -> false + end. + + +same(Algs) -> [{client2server,Algs}, {server2client,Algs}]. + + +%% default_algorithms(kex) -> % Example of how to disable an algorithm +%% supported_algorithms(kex, ['ecdh-sha2-nistp521']); + %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %% %% Other utils diff --git a/lib/ssh/test/ssh_renegotiate_SUITE.erl b/lib/ssh/test/ssh_renegotiate_SUITE.erl index ef631d54bd..227dfcddcd 100644 --- a/lib/ssh/test/ssh_renegotiate_SUITE.erl +++ b/lib/ssh/test/ssh_renegotiate_SUITE.erl @@ -32,9 +32,15 @@ suite() -> [{ct_hooks,[ts_install_cth]}]. -all() -> [rekey, rekey_limit, renegotiate1, renegotiate2]. +all() -> [{group,default_algs}, + {group,aes_gcm} + ]. -groups() -> []. +groups() -> [{default_algs, [], tests()}, + {aes_gcm, [], tests()} + ]. + +tests() -> [rekey, rekey_limit, renegotiate1, renegotiate2]. %%-------------------------------------------------------------------- init_per_suite(Config) -> @@ -50,6 +56,18 @@ end_per_suite(_Config) -> crypto:stop(). %%-------------------------------------------------------------------- +init_per_group(aes_gcm, Config) -> + [{preferred_algorithms, [{cipher,[{client2server,['[email protected]']}, + {server2client,['[email protected]']}]}]} + | Config]; +init_per_group(_, Config) -> + [{preferred_algorithms, ssh:default_algorithms()} | Config]. + + +end_per_group(_, Config) -> + Config. + +%%-------------------------------------------------------------------- init_per_testcase(_TestCase, Config) -> ssh:start(), Config. diff --git a/lib/ssh/test/ssh_test_lib.erl b/lib/ssh/test/ssh_test_lib.erl index 5816b708f2..424afc76fe 100644 --- a/lib/ssh/test/ssh_test_lib.erl +++ b/lib/ssh/test/ssh_test_lib.erl @@ -296,7 +296,7 @@ setup_dsa(DataDir, UserDir) -> file:make_dir(System), file:copy(filename:join(DataDir, "ssh_host_dsa_key"), filename:join(System, "ssh_host_dsa_key")), file:copy(filename:join(DataDir, "ssh_host_dsa_key.pub"), filename:join(System, "ssh_host_dsa_key.pub")), -ct:pal("DataDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nSystDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nUserDir ~p:~n ~p",[DataDir, file:list_dir(DataDir), System, file:list_dir(System), UserDir, file:list_dir(UserDir)]), +ct:log("DataDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nSystDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nUserDir ~p:~n ~p",[DataDir, file:list_dir(DataDir), System, file:list_dir(System), UserDir, file:list_dir(UserDir)]), setup_dsa_known_host(DataDir, UserDir), setup_dsa_auth_keys(DataDir, UserDir). @@ -306,7 +306,7 @@ setup_rsa(DataDir, UserDir) -> file:make_dir(System), file:copy(filename:join(DataDir, "ssh_host_rsa_key"), filename:join(System, "ssh_host_rsa_key")), file:copy(filename:join(DataDir, "ssh_host_rsa_key.pub"), filename:join(System, "ssh_host_rsa_key.pub")), -ct:pal("DataDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nSystDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nUserDir ~p:~n ~p",[DataDir, file:list_dir(DataDir), System, file:list_dir(System), UserDir, file:list_dir(UserDir)]), +ct:log("DataDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nSystDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nUserDir ~p:~n ~p",[DataDir, file:list_dir(DataDir), System, file:list_dir(System), UserDir, file:list_dir(UserDir)]), setup_rsa_known_host(DataDir, UserDir), setup_rsa_auth_keys(DataDir, UserDir). @@ -316,7 +316,7 @@ setup_ecdsa(Size, DataDir, UserDir) -> file:make_dir(System), file:copy(filename:join(DataDir, "ssh_host_ecdsa_key"++Size), filename:join(System, "ssh_host_ecdsa_key")), file:copy(filename:join(DataDir, "ssh_host_ecdsa_key"++Size++".pub"), filename:join(System, "ssh_host_ecdsa_key.pub")), -ct:pal("DataDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nSystDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nUserDir ~p:~n ~p",[DataDir, file:list_dir(DataDir), System, file:list_dir(System), UserDir, file:list_dir(UserDir)]), +ct:log("DataDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nSystDir ~p:~n ~p~n~nUserDir ~p:~n ~p",[DataDir, file:list_dir(DataDir), System, file:list_dir(System), UserDir, file:list_dir(UserDir)]), setup_ecdsa_known_host(Size, System, UserDir), setup_ecdsa_auth_keys(Size, UserDir, UserDir). @@ -502,7 +502,7 @@ default_algorithms(sshd, Host, Port) -> {user_interaction, false}]}])) catch _C:_E -> - ct:pal("***~p:~p: ~p:~p",[?MODULE,?LINE,_C,_E]), + ct:log("***~p:~p: ~p:~p",[?MODULE,?LINE,_C,_E]), [] end. @@ -522,7 +522,7 @@ default_algorithms(sshc, DaemonOptions) -> InitialState)) catch _C:_E -> - ct:pal("***~p:~p: ~p:~p",[?MODULE,?LINE,_C,_E]), + ct:log("***~p:~p: ~p:~p",[?MODULE,?LINE,_C,_E]), [] end} end), |