From 348b5e6bee2f83d10642558d511cc904f5015ab3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: =?UTF-8?q?Bj=C3=B6rn=20Gustavsson?= Date: Thu, 15 Sep 2016 16:33:57 +0200 Subject: v3_kernel: Generate optimized code for guards The compiler produces poor code for complex guard expressions with andalso/orelse. Here is an example from the filename module: -define(IS_DRIVELETTER(Letter),(((Letter >= $A) andalso (Letter =< $Z)) orelse ((Letter >= $a) andalso (Letter =< $z)))). skip_prefix(Name, false) -> Name; skip_prefix([L, DrvSep|Name], DrvSep) when ?IS_DRIVELETTER(L) -> Name; skip_prefix(Name, _) -> Name. beam_bool fails to simplify the code for the guard, leaving several 'bif' instructions: {function, skip_prefix, 2, 49}. {label,48}. {line,[{location,"filename.erl",187}]}. {func_info,{atom,filename},{atom,skip_prefix},2}. {label,49}. {test,is_ne_exact,{f,52},[{x,1},{atom,false}]}. {test,is_nonempty_list,{f,52},[{x,0}]}. {get_list,{x,0},{x,2},{x,3}}. {test,is_nonempty_list,{f,52},[{x,3}]}. {get_list,{x,3},{x,4},{x,5}}. {bif,'=:=',{f,52},[{x,1},{x,4}],{x,6}}. {test,is_ge,{f,50},[{x,2},{integer,65}]}. {bif,'=<',{f,52},[{x,2},{integer,90}],{x,7}}. {test,is_eq_exact,{f,51},[{x,7},{atom,false}]}. {test,is_ge,{f,50},[{x,2},{integer,97}]}. {bif,'=<',{f,52},[{x,2},{integer,122}],{x,7}}. {jump,{f,51}}. {label,50}. {move,{atom,false},{x,7}}. {label,51}. {bif,'=:=',{f,52},[{x,7},{atom,true}],{x,7}}. {test,is_eq_exact,{f,52},[{x,6},{atom,true}]}. {test,is_eq_exact,{f,52},[{x,7},{atom,true}]}. {move,{x,5},{x,0}}. return. {label,52}. return. We can add optimizations of guard tests to v3_kernel to achive a better result: {function, skip_prefix, 2, 49}. {label,48}. {line,[{location,"filename.erl",187}]}. {func_info,{atom,filename},{atom,skip_prefix},2}. {label,49}. {test,is_ne_exact,{f,51},[{x,1},{atom,false}]}. {test,is_nonempty_list,{f,51},[{x,0}]}. {get_list,{x,0},{x,2},{x,3}}. {test,is_nonempty_list,{f,51},[{x,3}]}. {get_list,{x,3},{x,4},{x,5}}. {test,is_eq_exact,{f,51},[{x,1},{x,4}]}. {test,is_ge,{f,51},[{x,2},{integer,65}]}. {test,is_lt,{f,50},[{integer,90},{x,2}]}. {test,is_ge,{f,51},[{x,2},{integer,97}]}. {test,is_ge,{f,51},[{integer,122},{x,2}]}. {label,50}. {move,{x,5},{x,0}}. return. {label,51}. return. Looking at the STDLIB application, there were 112 lines of BIF calls in guards that beam_bool failed to convert to test instructions. This commit eliminates all those BIF calls. Here is how I counted the instructions: $ PATH=$ERL_TOP/bin:$PATH erlc -I ../include -I ../../kernel/include -S *.erl $ grep "bif,'[=<>]" *.S | grep -v f,0 dets.S: {bif,'=:=',{f,547},[{x,4},{atom,read_write}],{x,4}}. dets.S: {bif,'=:=',{f,547},[{x,5},{atom,saved}],{x,5}}. dets.S: {bif,'=:=',{f,589},[{x,5},{atom,read}],{x,5}}. . . . $ grep "bif,'[=<>]" *.S | grep -v f,0 | wc 112 224 6765 $ --- .../test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_1.core | 147 +++++++++++++++++++++ .../test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_2.core | 98 ++++++++++++++ .../test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_3.core | 98 ++++++++++++++ .../test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_4.core | 82 ++++++++++++ .../test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_5.core | 98 ++++++++++++++ 5 files changed, 523 insertions(+) create mode 100644 lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_1.core create mode 100644 lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_2.core create mode 100644 lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_3.core create mode 100644 lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_4.core create mode 100644 lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_5.core (limited to 'lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data') diff --git a/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_1.core b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_1.core new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9e5788796f --- /dev/null +++ b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_1.core @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +module 'cover_v3_kernel_1' ['cover_v3_kernel_1'/0, + 'module_info'/0, + 'module_info'/1] + attributes [] +'cover_v3_kernel_1'/0 = + %% Line 4 + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + %% Line 5 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/1 + ('x') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 7 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/2 + (1, 2) of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 8 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/2 + (1, 'true') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 9 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/2 + ('true', 42) of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 10 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/2 + ('true', 'false') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 11 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/2 + ('false', 'true') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 12 + case apply 'bad_and_args'/2 + ('true', 'true') of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 14 + 'ok' + ( <_@c6> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c6}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c5> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c5}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c4> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c4}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c3> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c3}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c2> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c2}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c1> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c1}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c0> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c0}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'cover_v3_kernel_1',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'bad_and_args'/1 = + %% Line 16 + fun (_@c0) -> + case _@c0 of + + when try + call 'erlang':'and'(A, 42) + of -> + Try + catch -> + 'false' -> + 'ok' + %% Line 17 + <_@c4> when 'true' -> + 'error' + ( <_@c3> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_@c3}) + -| [{'function_name',{'bad_and_args',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'bad_and_args'/2 = + %% Line 19 + fun (_@c1,_@c0) -> + case <_@c1,_@c0> of + + when try + call 'erlang':'and'(X, Y) + of -> + Try + catch -> + 'false' -> + 'ok' + %% Line 20 + <_@c6,_@c7> when 'true' -> + 'error' + ( <_@c5,_@c4> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_@c5,_@c4}) + -| [{'function_name',{'bad_and_args',2}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/0 = + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_1') + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/1 = + fun (_@c0) -> + case _@c0 of + when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_1', X) + ( <_@c1> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_@c1}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +end diff --git a/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_2.core b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_2.core new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..165aacd691 --- /dev/null +++ b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_2.core @@ -0,0 +1,98 @@ +module 'cover_v3_kernel_2' ['cover_v3_kernel_2'/0, + 'module_info'/0, + 'module_info'/1] + attributes [] +'cover_v3_kernel_2'/0 = + %% Line 4 + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + %% Line 5 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + ('a') of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 6 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + ('b') of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 7 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + ('c') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 8 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (42) of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 9 + 'ok' + ( <_cor3> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor3}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor2> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor2}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor1> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor1}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor0> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor0}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'cover_v3_kernel_2',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'strange_case'/1 = + %% Line 12 + fun (_cor0) -> + case _cor0 of + when + case X of + <'a'> when 'true' -> 'true' + <'b'> when 'true' -> 'true' + when 'true' -> 'false' + end -> + 'ok' + %% Line 13 + <_cor4> when 'true' -> + 'error' + ( <_cor3> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_cor3}) + -| [{'function_name',{'strange_case',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/0 = + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_2') + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/1 = + fun (_cor0) -> + case _cor0 of + when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_2', X) + ( <_cor1> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_cor1}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +end diff --git a/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_3.core b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_3.core new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..88a9edc354 --- /dev/null +++ b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_3.core @@ -0,0 +1,98 @@ +module 'cover_v3_kernel_3' ['cover_v3_kernel_3'/0, + 'module_info'/0, + 'module_info'/1] + attributes [] +'cover_v3_kernel_3'/0 = + %% Line 4 + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + %% Line 5 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (1) of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 6 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (2) of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 7 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (42) of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 8 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + ('atom') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 9 + 'ok' + ( <_cor3> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor3}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor2> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor2}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor1> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor1}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor0> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor0}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'cover_v3_kernel_3',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'strange_case'/1 = + %% Line 12 + fun (_cor0) -> + case _cor0 of + when + case X of + <1> when 'true' -> 'true' + <2> when 'true' -> 'true' + when 'true' -> 'false' + end -> + 'ok' + %% Line 13 + <_cor4> when 'true' -> + 'error' + ( <_cor3> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_cor3}) + -| [{'function_name',{'strange_case',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/0 = + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_3') + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/1 = + fun (_cor0) -> + case _cor0 of + when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_3', X) + ( <_cor1> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_cor1}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +end diff --git a/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_4.core b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_4.core new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..905e236f26 --- /dev/null +++ b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_4.core @@ -0,0 +1,82 @@ +module 'cover_v3_kernel_4' ['cover_v3_kernel_4'/0, + 'module_info'/0, + 'module_info'/1] + attributes [] +'cover_v3_kernel_4'/0 = + %% Line 4 + fun () -> + %% Line 5 + case apply 'turned_case'/1 + (20) of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 6 + case apply 'turned_case'/1 + (0) of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 7 + 'ok' + ( <_@c1> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c1}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_@c0> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_@c0}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'turned_case'/1 = + %% Line 9 + fun (_@c0) -> + let = + apply %% Line 10 + 'id'/1 + (%% Line 10 + 'true') + in %% Line 11 + case <> of + %% Line 12 + <> + when try + ( let <_@c4> = + case call 'erlang':'<' + (_@c0, 10) of + ( <( 'false' + -| ['compiler_generated'] )> when 'true' -> + True + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + ( <( 'true' + -| ['compiler_generated'] )> when 'true' -> + 'false' + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + ( <_@c2> when 'true' -> + _@c2 + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + in ( call 'erlang':'=:=' + (( _@c4 + -| ['compiler_generated'] ), 'true') + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + of -> + Try + catch -> + 'false' -> + 'ok' + %% Line 13 + <> when 'true' -> + 'error' + end +'id'/1 = + %% Line 16 + fun (_@c0) -> + _@c0 +'module_info'/0 = + fun () -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_4') +'module_info'/1 = + fun (_@c0) -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_4', _@c0) +end \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_5.core b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_5.core new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..48c1bb84e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/lib/compiler/test/core_SUITE_data/cover_v3_kernel_5.core @@ -0,0 +1,98 @@ +module 'cover_v3_kernel_5' ['cover_v3_kernel_5'/0, + 'module_info'/0, + 'module_info'/1] + attributes [] +'cover_v3_kernel_5'/0 = + %% Line 4 + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + %% Line 5 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (1) of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 6 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (2) of + <'ok'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 7 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + (42) of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 8 + case apply 'strange_case'/1 + ('atom') of + <'error'> when 'true' -> + %% Line 9 + 'ok' + ( <_cor3> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor3}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor2> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor2}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor1> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor1}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <_cor0> when 'true' -> + primop 'match_fail' + ({'badmatch',_cor0}) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'cover_v3_kernel_5',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'strange_case'/1 = + %% Line 12 + fun (_cor0) -> + case _cor0 of + when + case X of + <1> when 'true' -> 'true' + <2> when 'true' -> 'true' + when 'true' -> X + end -> + 'ok' + %% Line 13 + <_cor4> when 'true' -> + 'error' + ( <_cor3> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_cor3}) + -| [{'function_name',{'strange_case',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/0 = + fun () -> + case <> of + <> when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_5') + ( <> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause'}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',0}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +'module_info'/1 = + fun (_cor0) -> + case _cor0 of + when 'true' -> + call 'erlang':'get_module_info' + ('cover_v3_kernel_5', X) + ( <_cor1> when 'true' -> + ( primop 'match_fail' + ({'function_clause',_cor1}) + -| [{'function_name',{'module_info',1}}] ) + -| ['compiler_generated'] ) + end +end -- cgit v1.2.3