ssl: Improve openssl interop tests

openssl 1.1.x changed the default ECC curves that made testcases
fail in the ECC suite. openssl s_server and s_client sent
'Illegal Parameter' alert when the CertificateVerify (client) or
ServerKeyExchange (server) message was signed with a curve that
was not present in openssl's default ECC curve list (x25519,
secp256r1, secp521r1, secp384r1, brainpoolP256r1, brainpoolP384r1,
brainpool512r1).

This commit changes the default curve of make_ec_cert_chains to
'secp256r1' and explicitly configures the default curve in
those testcases where the default curve of the ssl application
is expected.

Change-Id: I81ebe1a30b8f863b0e2836b1dad3d8bc767cc47e

2 files changed, 64 insertions, 39 deletions

diff --git a/lib/ssl/test/ssl_ECC_SUITE.erl b/lib/ssl/test/ssl_ECC_SUITE.erl
index a5309e866b..ca8d0ec70c 100644
--- a/lib/ssl/test/ssl_ECC_SUITE.erl
+++ b/lib/ssl/test/ssl_ECC_SUITE.erl
@@ -212,53 +212,61 @@ client_ecdsa_server_ecdsa_with_raw_key(Config)  when is_list(Config) ->
 
 ecc_default_order(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
-                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),   
+                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa,
+                                                        Config, DefaultCurve),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
     ECCOpts = [],
-    case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs([{eccs, [sect571r1]}]) of
-        true ->  ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(sect571r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
+    case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs([{eccs, [DefaultCurve]}]) of
+        true ->  ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(DefaultCurve, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
      end.
 
 ecc_default_order_custom_curves(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
-                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),   
+                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa,
+                                                        Config, DefaultCurve),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
-         true ->  ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(sect571r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
+         true ->  ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(DefaultCurve, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
     end.
 
 ecc_client_order(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
-                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),   
+                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa,
+                                                        Config, DefaultCurve),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
     ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, false}],
-    case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs([{eccs, [sect571r1]}]) of
-         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(sect571r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
+    case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs([{eccs, [DefaultCurve]}]) of
+         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(DefaultCurve, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
     end.
 
 ecc_client_order_custom_curves(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default},
                                                         {client_chain, Default}],
-                                                      ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),   
+                                                        ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa,
+                                                        Config, DefaultCurve),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, false}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, false}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
-        true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(sect571r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
+        true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(DefaultCurve, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
     end.
 
@@ -274,12 +282,13 @@ ecc_unknown_curve(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdh_rsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default},
                                                        {client_chain, Default}], 
                                                         ecdh_rsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
      case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
          true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
          false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
@@ -287,12 +296,13 @@ client_ecdh_rsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdh_rsa_server_ecdhe_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
                                                         ecdh_rsa, ecdhe_rsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-     ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
@@ -301,12 +311,13 @@ client_ecdh_rsa_server_ecdhe_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
                                                         ecdhe_rsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
          true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
@@ -314,19 +325,21 @@ client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdhe_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}], 
                                                         ecdhe_rsa, ecdhe_rsa, Config),
 
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
      end.
 client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdh_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     Ext = x509_test:extensions([{key_usage, [keyEncipherment]}]),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, [[], [], [{extensions, Ext}]]},
                                                          {client_chain, Default}], 
@@ -334,8 +347,8 @@ client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdh_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
-    Expected = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))), %% The certificate curve
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
+    Expected = secp256r1, %% The certificate curve
 
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(Expected, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
@@ -344,12 +357,13 @@ client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdh_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                        {client_chain, Default}], 
                                                         ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
@@ -357,12 +371,13 @@ client_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_ecdhe_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
                                                         ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_rsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{honor_ecc_order, true}, {eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, [], ECCOpts, Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
@@ -370,12 +385,13 @@ client_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_ecdhe_rsa_server_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_client_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                        {client_chain, Default}],
                                                         ecdhe_ecdsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, ECCOpts, [], Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
@@ -383,12 +399,13 @@ client_ecdhe_ecdsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_client_custom(Config) ->
 
 client_ecdhe_rsa_server_ecdhe_ecdsa_client_custom(Config) ->
     Default = ssl_test_lib:default_cert_chain_conf(),
+    DefaultCurve = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0))),
     {COpts0, SOpts0} = ssl_test_lib:make_ec_cert_chains([{server_chain, Default}, 
                                                          {client_chain, Default}],
                                                          ecdhe_rsa, ecdhe_ecdsa, Config),
     COpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(COpts0, Config), 
     SOpts = ssl_test_lib:ssl_options(SOpts0, Config),
-    ECCOpts = [{eccs, [secp256r1, sect571r1]}],
+    ECCOpts = [{eccs, [secp256r1, DefaultCurve]}],
     case ssl_test_lib:supported_eccs(ECCOpts) of
         true -> ssl_test_lib:ecc_test(secp256r1, COpts, SOpts, ECCOpts, [], Config);
         false -> {skip, "unsupported named curves"}
diff --git a/lib/ssl/test/ssl_test_lib.erl b/lib/ssl/test/ssl_test_lib.erl
index a8d62d6c4e..2d69bd5a12 100644
--- a/lib/ssl/test/ssl_test_lib.erl
+++ b/lib/ssl/test/ssl_test_lib.erl
@@ -30,6 +30,7 @@
 
 -record(sslsocket, { fd = nil, pid = nil}).
 -define(SLEEP, 1000).
+-define(DEFAULT_CURVE, secp256r1).
 
 %% For now always run locally
 run_where(_) ->
@@ -618,9 +619,12 @@ make_rsa_cert_chains(UserConf, Config, Suffix) ->
     }.
 
 make_ec_cert_chains(UserConf, ClientChainType, ServerChainType, Config) ->
+    make_ec_cert_chains(UserConf, ClientChainType, ServerChainType, Config, ?DEFAULT_CURVE).
+%%
+make_ec_cert_chains(UserConf, ClientChainType, ServerChainType, Config, Curve) ->
     ClientChain = proplists:get_value(client_chain, UserConf, default_cert_chain_conf()),
     ServerChain = proplists:get_value(server_chain, UserConf, default_cert_chain_conf()),
-    CertChainConf = gen_conf(ClientChainType, ServerChainType, ClientChain, ServerChain),
+    CertChainConf = gen_conf(ClientChainType, ServerChainType, ClientChain, ServerChain, Curve),
     ClientFileBase = filename:join([proplists:get_value(priv_dir, Config), atom_to_list(ClientChainType)]),
     ServerFileBase = filename:join([proplists:get_value(priv_dir, Config), atom_to_list(ServerChainType)]),
     GenCertData = public_key:pkix_test_data(CertChainConf),
@@ -635,7 +639,11 @@ default_cert_chain_conf() ->
     %% Use only default options
     [[],[],[]].
 
-gen_conf(mix, mix, UserClient, UserServer) ->
+
+gen_conf(ClientChainType, ServerChainType, UserClient, UserServer) ->
+    gen_conf(ClientChainType, ServerChainType, UserClient, UserServer, ?DEFAULT_CURVE).
+%%
+gen_conf(mix, mix, UserClient, UserServer, _) ->
     ClientTag = conf_tag("client"),
     ServerTag = conf_tag("server"),
 
@@ -646,12 +654,12 @@ gen_conf(mix, mix, UserClient, UserServer) ->
     ServerConf = merge_chain_spec(UserServer, DefaultServer, []),
     
     new_format([{ClientTag, ClientConf}, {ServerTag, ServerConf}]);
-gen_conf(ClientChainType, ServerChainType, UserClient, UserServer) ->
+gen_conf(ClientChainType, ServerChainType, UserClient, UserServer, Curve) ->
     ClientTag = conf_tag("client"),
     ServerTag = conf_tag("server"),
 
-    DefaultClient = chain_spec(client, ClientChainType), 
-    DefaultServer = chain_spec(server, ServerChainType),
+    DefaultClient = chain_spec(client, ClientChainType, Curve),
+    DefaultServer = chain_spec(server, ServerChainType, Curve),
     
     ClientConf = merge_chain_spec(UserClient, DefaultClient, []),
     ServerConf = merge_chain_spec(UserServer, DefaultServer, []),
@@ -673,43 +681,43 @@ proplist_to_map([Head | Rest]) ->
 conf_tag(Role) ->
     list_to_atom(Role ++ "_chain").
 
-chain_spec(_Role, ecdh_rsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, ecdh_rsa, Curve) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
-    CurveOid = hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0)),
+    CurveOid = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(Curve),
      [[Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
       [Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(1)}],
       [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}]];
 
-chain_spec(_Role, ecdhe_ecdsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, ecdhe_ecdsa, Curve) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
-    CurveOid = hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0)),
+    CurveOid = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(Curve),
     [[Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
      [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
      [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}]];
 
-chain_spec(_Role, ecdh_ecdsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, ecdh_ecdsa, Curve) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
-    CurveOid = hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0)),
+    CurveOid = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(Curve),
     [[Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
      [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
      [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}]];
-chain_spec(_Role, ecdhe_rsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, ecdhe_rsa, _) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
     [[Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(1)}],
      [Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(2)}],
      [Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(3)}]];
-chain_spec(_Role, ecdsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, ecdsa, Curve) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
-    CurveOid = hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0)),
+    CurveOid = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(Curve),
     [[Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
      [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}],
      [Digest, {key, {namedCurve, CurveOid}}]];
-chain_spec(_Role, rsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, rsa, _) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
     [[Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(1)}],
                                       [Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(2)}],
                                       [Digest, {key, hardcode_rsa_key(3)}]];
-chain_spec(_Role, dsa) ->
+chain_spec(_Role, dsa, _) ->
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
     [[Digest, {key, hardcode_dsa_key(1)}],
      [Digest, {key, hardcode_dsa_key(2)}],
@@ -742,7 +750,7 @@ merge_spec(User, Default, [Conf | Rest], Acc) ->
 make_mix_cert(Config) ->
     Ext = x509_test:extensions([{key_usage, [digitalSignature]}]),
     Digest = {digest, appropriate_sha(crypto:supports())},
-    CurveOid = hd(tls_v1:ecc_curves(0)),
+    CurveOid = pubkey_cert_records:namedCurves(?DEFAULT_CURVE),
     Mix = proplists:get_value(mix, Config, peer_ecc),
     ClientChainType =ServerChainType = mix,
     {ClientChain, ServerChain} = mix(Mix, Digest, CurveOid, Ext),