diff options
author | Erlang/OTP <[email protected]> | 2018-08-23 14:47:11 +0200 |
---|---|---|
committer | Erlang/OTP <[email protected]> | 2018-08-23 14:47:11 +0200 |
commit | d7647faf260a736384c24f73a1205ad946552a31 (patch) | |
tree | 7b221be6df7aef87ae8e8e8ba917b6161b52d869 /lib | |
parent | 40a2b9e7777a2314ebce1e15d5b366abf129a7aa (diff) | |
parent | b7d7cc2c3ce83c1206c3ba98a2b90958f4c50693 (diff) | |
download | otp-d7647faf260a736384c24f73a1205ad946552a31.tar.gz otp-d7647faf260a736384c24f73a1205ad946552a31.tar.bz2 otp-d7647faf260a736384c24f73a1205ad946552a31.zip |
Merge branch 'lars/crypto/multiple-engine-load-21/OTP-15233' into maint-21
* lars/crypto/multiple-engine-load-21/OTP-15233:
Updated the engine load functionality
Diffstat (limited to 'lib')
-rw-r--r-- | lib/crypto/c_src/crypto.c | 52 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/crypto/doc/src/crypto.xml | 261 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/crypto/doc/src/engine_load.xml | 31 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/crypto/src/crypto.erl | 172 | ||||
-rw-r--r-- | lib/crypto/test/engine_SUITE.erl | 278 |
5 files changed, 689 insertions, 105 deletions
diff --git a/lib/crypto/c_src/crypto.c b/lib/crypto/c_src/crypto.c index f8d1778bb9..7f0dd28020 100644 --- a/lib/crypto/c_src/crypto.c +++ b/lib/crypto/c_src/crypto.c @@ -536,6 +536,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_remove_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TE static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_first_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM argv[]); static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_next_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM argv[]); static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_id_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM argv[]); +static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_name_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM argv[]); static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_all_methods_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM argv[]); /* helpers */ @@ -625,6 +626,7 @@ static ErlNifFunc nif_funcs[] = { {"engine_get_first_nif", 0, engine_get_first_nif}, {"engine_get_next_nif", 1, engine_get_next_nif}, {"engine_get_id_nif", 1, engine_get_id_nif}, + {"engine_get_name_nif", 1, engine_get_name_nif}, {"engine_get_all_methods_nif", 0, engine_get_all_methods_nif} }; @@ -4876,7 +4878,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM pkey_crypt_nif(ErlNifEnv *env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM } else { /* non-evp rsa private decrypt */ i = RSA_private_decrypt(in_bin.size, in_bin.data, - out_bin.data, rsa, crypt_opt.rsa_padding); + out_bin.data, rsa, crypt_opt.rsa_padding); if (i > 0) { ERL_VALGRIND_MAKE_MEM_DEFINED(out_bin.data, i); enif_realloc_binary(&out_bin, i); @@ -4894,7 +4896,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM pkey_crypt_nif(ErlNifEnv *env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM } else { /* non-evp rsa public decrypt */ i = RSA_public_decrypt(in_bin.size, in_bin.data, - out_bin.data, rsa, crypt_opt.rsa_padding); + out_bin.data, rsa, crypt_opt.rsa_padding); if (i > 0) { ERL_VALGRIND_MAKE_MEM_DEFINED(out_bin.data, i); enif_realloc_binary(&out_bin, i); @@ -5012,7 +5014,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM privkey_to_pubkey_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NI / * Example of result: { Curve = {Field, Prime, Point, Order, CoFactor} = - { + { Field = {prime_field,<<255,...,255>>}, Prime = {<<255,...,252>>, <<90,...,75>>, @@ -5025,9 +5027,9 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM privkey_to_pubkey_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NI Key = <<151,...,62>> } or - { + { Curve = - {characteristic_two_field, + {characteristic_two_field, M, Basis = {tpbasis, _} | {ppbasis, k1, k2, k3} @@ -5040,7 +5042,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM privkey_to_pubkey_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NI */ #endif } - + if (pkey) EVP_PKEY_free(pkey); return enif_make_badarg(env); } @@ -5221,7 +5223,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_ctrl_cmd_strings_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const error: for(i = 0; cmds != NULL && cmds[i] != NULL; i++) - enif_free(cmds[i]); + enif_free(cmds[i]); enif_free(cmds); return ret; #else @@ -5539,7 +5541,7 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_id_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TE if (!engine_id) { enif_alloc_binary(0, &engine_id_bin); engine_id_bin.size = 0; - return enif_make_tuple2(env, atom_ok, enif_make_binary(env, &engine_id_bin)); + return enif_make_binary(env, &engine_id_bin); } size = strlen(engine_id); @@ -5547,7 +5549,39 @@ static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_id_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TE engine_id_bin.size = size; memcpy(engine_id_bin.data, engine_id, size); - return enif_make_tuple2(env, atom_ok, enif_make_binary(env, &engine_id_bin)); + return enif_make_binary(env, &engine_id_bin); +#else + return atom_notsup; +#endif +} + +static ERL_NIF_TERM engine_get_name_nif(ErlNifEnv* env, int argc, const ERL_NIF_TERM argv[]) +{/* (Engine) */ +#ifdef HAS_ENGINE_SUPPORT + ErlNifBinary engine_name_bin; + const char *engine_name; + int size; + struct engine_ctx *ctx; + + // Get Engine + if (!enif_get_resource(env, argv[0], engine_ctx_rtype, (void**)&ctx)) { + PRINTF_ERR0("engine_get_id_nif Leaved: Parameter not an engine resource object"); + return enif_make_badarg(env); + } + + engine_name = ENGINE_get_name(ctx->engine); + if (!engine_name) { + enif_alloc_binary(0, &engine_name_bin); + engine_name_bin.size = 0; + return enif_make_binary(env, &engine_name_bin); + } + + size = strlen(engine_name); + enif_alloc_binary(size, &engine_name_bin); + engine_name_bin.size = size; + memcpy(engine_name_bin.data, engine_name, size); + + return enif_make_binary(env, &engine_name_bin); #else return atom_notsup; #endif diff --git a/lib/crypto/doc/src/crypto.xml b/lib/crypto/doc/src/crypto.xml index 42e411a0e3..e6147ddffc 100644 --- a/lib/crypto/doc/src/crypto.xml +++ b/lib/crypto/doc/src/crypto.xml @@ -143,7 +143,7 @@ password => password()}</code> <code>engine_ref() = term()</code> - <p>The result of a call to <seealso marker="#engine_load-3">engine_load/3</seealso>. + <p>The result of a call to for example <seealso marker="#engine_load-3">engine_load/3</seealso>. </p> <code>key_id() = string() | binary()</code> @@ -629,7 +629,7 @@ <desc> <p>Fetches the corresponding public key from a private key stored in an Engine. The key must be of the type indicated by the Type parameter. - </p> + </p> </desc> </func> @@ -1075,8 +1075,8 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <p> Returns a list of all possible engine methods. </p> - <p> - May throw exception notsup in case there is + <p> + May throw exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> <p> @@ -1092,18 +1092,18 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <type> <v>EngineId = unicode:chardata()</v> <v>PreCmds, PostCmds = [{unicode:chardata(), unicode:chardata()}]</v> - <v>Result = {ok, Engine::term()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + <v>Result = {ok, Engine::engine_ref()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> </type> <desc> <p> Loads the OpenSSL engine given by <c>EngineId</c> if it is available and then returns ok and - an engine handle. This function is the same as calling <c>engine_load/4</c> with - <c>EngineMethods</c> set to a list of all the possible methods. An error tuple is + an engine handle. This function is the same as calling <c>engine_load/4</c> with + <c>EngineMethods</c> set to a list of all the possible methods. An error tuple is returned if the engine can't be loaded. </p> <p> The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. - It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> <p> @@ -1120,7 +1120,7 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <v>EngineId = unicode:chardata()</v> <v>PreCmds, PostCmds = [{unicode:chardata(), unicode:chardata()}]</v> <v>EngineMethods = [engine_method_type()]</v> - <v>Result = {ok, Engine::term()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + <v>Result = {ok, Engine::engine_ref()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> </type> <desc> <p> @@ -1129,7 +1129,7 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> </p> <p> The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. - It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> <p> @@ -1143,17 +1143,17 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <name>engine_unload(Engine) -> Result</name> <fsummary>Dynamical load an encryption engine</fsummary> <type> - <v>Engine = term()</v> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> <v>Result = ok | {error, Reason::term()}</v> </type> <desc> <p> - Unloads the OpenSSL engine given by <c>EngineId</c>. + Unloads the OpenSSL engine given by <c>Engine</c>. An error tuple is returned if the engine can't be unloaded. </p> <p> The function throws a badarg if the parameter is in wrong format. - It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> <p> @@ -1164,19 +1164,24 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> </func> <func> - <name>engine_list() -> Result</name> - <fsummary>List the known engine ids</fsummary> + <name>engine_by_id(EngineId) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Get a reference to an already loaded engine</fsummary> <type> - <v>Result = [EngineId::unicode:chardata()]</v> + <v>EngineID = unicode:chardata()engine_ref()</v> + <v>Result = {ok, Engine::engine_ref()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> </type> <desc> - <p>List the id's of all engines in OpenSSL's internal list.</p> <p> - It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + Get a reference to an already loaded engine with <c>EngineId</c>. + An error tuple is returned if the engine can't be unloaded. + </p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameter is in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> <p> - See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> + See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> in the User's Guide. </p> </desc> @@ -1186,7 +1191,7 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <name>engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine, CmdName, CmdArg) -> Result</name> <fsummary>Sends ctrl commands to an OpenSSL engine</fsummary> <type> - <v>Engine = term()</v> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> <v>CmdName = unicode:chardata()</v> <v>CmdArg = unicode:chardata()</v> <v>Result = ok | {error, Reason::term()}</v> @@ -1194,12 +1199,12 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <desc> <p> Sends ctrl commands to the OpenSSL engine given by <c>Engine</c>. - This function is the same as calling <c>engine_ctrl_cmd_string/4</c> with + This function is the same as calling <c>engine_ctrl_cmd_string/4</c> with <c>Optional</c> set to <c>false</c>. </p> <p> The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. - It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> </desc> @@ -1209,7 +1214,7 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <name>engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine, CmdName, CmdArg, Optional) -> Result</name> <fsummary>Sends ctrl commands to an OpenSSL engine</fsummary> <type> - <v>Engine = term()</v> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> <v>CmdName = unicode:chardata()</v> <v>CmdArg = unicode:chardata()</v> <v>Optional = boolean()</v> @@ -1218,18 +1223,218 @@ _FloatValue = rand:uniform(). % [0.0; 1.0[</pre> <desc> <p> Sends ctrl commands to the OpenSSL engine given by <c>Engine</c>. - <c>Optional</c> is a boolean argument that can relax the semantics of the function. - If set to <c>true</c> it will only return failure if the ENGINE supported the given - command name but failed while executing it, if the ENGINE doesn't support the command - name it will simply return success without doing anything. In this case we assume + <c>Optional</c> is a boolean argument that can relax the semantics of the function. + If set to <c>true</c> it will only return failure if the ENGINE supported the given + command name but failed while executing it, if the ENGINE doesn't support the command + name it will simply return success without doing anything. In this case we assume the user is only supplying commands specific to the given ENGINE so we set this to <c>false</c>. </p> <p> The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. - It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>engine_add(Engine) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Add engine to OpenSSL internal list</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> + <v>Result = ok | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p>Add the engine to OpenSSL's internal list.</p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>engine_remove(Engine) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Remove engine to OpenSSL internal list</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> + <v>Result = ok | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p>Remove the engine from OpenSSL's internal list.</p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>engine_get_id(Engine) -> EngineId</name> + <fsummary>Fetch engine ID</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> + <v>EngineId = unicode:chardata()</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p>Return the ID for the engine, or an empty binary if there is no id set.</p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>engine_get_name(Engine) -> EngineName</name> + <fsummary>Fetch engine name</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> + <v>EngineName = unicode:chardata()</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p>Return the name (eg a description) for the engine, or an empty binary if there is no name set.</p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>engine_list() -> Result</name> + <fsummary>List the known engine ids</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Result = [EngineId::unicode:chardata()]</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p>List the id's of all engines in OpenSSL's internal list.</p> + <p> + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + <p> + See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> + in the User's Guide. + </p> + <p> + May throw exception notsup in case engine functionality is not supported by the underlying + OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>ensure_engine_loaded(EngineId, LibPath) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Ensure encryption engine just loaded once</fsummary> + <type> + <v>EngineId = unicode:chardata()</v> + <v>LibPath = unicode:chardata()</v> + <v>Result = {ok, Engine::engine_ref()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p> + Loads the OpenSSL engine given by <c>EngineId</c> and the path to the dynamic library + implementing the engine. This function is the same as calling <c>ensure_engine_loaded/3</c> with + <c>EngineMethods</c> set to a list of all the possible methods. An error tuple is + returned if the engine can't be loaded. + </p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. </p> + <p> + See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> + in the User's Guide. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>ensure_engine_loaded(EngineId, LibPath, EngineMethods) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Ensure encryption engine just loaded once</fsummary> + <type> + <v>EngineId = unicode:chardata()</v> + <v>LibPath = unicode:chardata()</v> + <v>EngineMethods = [engine_method_type()]</v> + <v>Result = {ok, Engine::engine_ref()} | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p> + Loads the OpenSSL engine given by <c>EngineId</c> and the path to the dynamic library + implementing the engine. This function differs from the normal engine_load in that sense it + also add the engine id to the internal list in OpenSSL. Then in the following calls to the function + it just fetch the reference to the engine instead of loading it again. + An error tuple is returned if the engine can't be loaded. + </p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + <p> + See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> + in the User's Guide. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>ensure_engine_unloaded(Engine) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Unload an engine loaded with the ensure function</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> + <v>Result = ok | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p> + Unloads an engine loaded with the <c>ensure_engine_loaded</c> function. + It both removes the label from the OpenSSL internal engine list and unloads the engine. + This function is the same as calling <c>ensure_engine_unloaded/2</c> with + <c>EngineMethods</c> set to a list of all the possible methods. An error tuple is + returned if the engine can't be unloaded. + </p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + <p> + See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> + in the User's Guide. + </p> + </desc> + </func> + + <func> + <name>ensure_engine_unloaded(Engine, EngineMethods) -> Result</name> + <fsummary>Unload an engine loaded with the ensure function</fsummary> + <type> + <v>Engine = engine_ref()</v> + <v>EngineMethods = [engine_method_type()]</v> + <v>Result = ok | {error, Reason::term()}</v> + </type> + <desc> + <p> + Unloads an engine loaded with the <c>ensure_engine_loaded</c> function. + It both removes the label from the OpenSSL internal engine list and unloads the engine. + An error tuple is returned if the engine can't be unloaded. + </p> + <p> + The function throws a badarg if the parameters are in wrong format. + It may also throw the exception notsup in case there is + no engine support in the underlying OpenSSL implementation. + </p> + <p> + See also the chapter <seealso marker="crypto:engine_load#engine_load">Engine Load</seealso> + in the User's Guide. + </p> </desc> </func> diff --git a/lib/crypto/doc/src/engine_load.xml b/lib/crypto/doc/src/engine_load.xml index e5c3f5d561..3d0aa0c32a 100644 --- a/lib/crypto/doc/src/engine_load.xml +++ b/lib/crypto/doc/src/engine_load.xml @@ -42,6 +42,9 @@ operations. The hardware implementation usually offers improved performance over its software-based counterpart, which is known as cryptographic acceleration. </p> + <note> + <p>The file name requirement on the engine dynamic library can differ between SSL versions.</p> + </note> </section> <section> @@ -54,9 +57,6 @@ <code> 1> {ok, Engine} = crypto:engine_load(<<"otp_test_engine">>, [], []). {ok, #Ref}</code> - <note> - <p>The file name requirement on the engine dynamic library can differ between SSL versions.</p> - </note> </section> <section> @@ -72,9 +72,6 @@ <<"LOAD">>], []). {ok, #Ref}</code> - <note> - <p>The dynamic engine is not supported in LibreSSL from version 2.2.1</p> - </note> </section> <section> @@ -100,6 +97,28 @@ engine_method_pkey_meths, engine_method_pkey_asn1_meths]. </section> <section> + <title>Load with the ensure loaded function</title> + <p> + This function makes sure the engine is loaded just once and the ID is added to the internal + engine list of OpenSSL. The following calls to the function will check if the ID is loaded + and then just get a new reference to the engine. + </p> + <code> + 5> {ok, Engine} = crypto:ensure_engine_loaded(<<"MD5">>, + <<"/some/path/otp_test_engine.so">>). + {ok, #Ref}</code> + <p> + To unload it use crypto:ensure_engine_unloaded/1 which removes the ID from the internal list + before unloading the engine. + </p> + <code> + 6> crypto:ensure_engine_unloaded(<<"MD5">>). + ok</code> + </section> + + + + <section> <title>List all engines currently loaded</title> <code> 5> crypto:engine_list(). diff --git a/lib/crypto/src/crypto.erl b/lib/crypto/src/crypto.erl index 714cba58b9..11e5ab327d 100644 --- a/lib/crypto/src/crypto.erl +++ b/lib/crypto/src/crypto.erl @@ -51,9 +51,18 @@ engine_load/3, engine_load/4, engine_unload/1, + engine_by_id/1, engine_list/0, engine_ctrl_cmd_string/3, - engine_ctrl_cmd_string/4 + engine_ctrl_cmd_string/4, + engine_add/1, + engine_remove/1, + engine_get_id/1, + engine_get_name/1, + ensure_engine_loaded/2, + ensure_engine_loaded/3, + ensure_engine_unloaded/1, + ensure_engine_unloaded/2 ]). -export_type([engine_ref/0, @@ -488,7 +497,7 @@ sign(Algorithm, Type, Data, Key, Options) -> -type engine_key_ref() :: #{engine := engine_ref(), key_id := key_id(), password => password(), - term() => term() + term() => term() }. -type pk_algs() :: rsa | ecdsa | dss . @@ -664,7 +673,7 @@ evp_compute_key_nif(_Curve, _OthersBin, _MyBin) -> ?nif_stub. -type engine_method_type() :: engine_method_rsa | engine_method_dsa | engine_method_dh | engine_method_rand | engine_method_ecdh | engine_method_ecdsa | engine_method_ciphers | engine_method_digests | engine_method_store | - engine_method_pkey_meths | engine_method_pkey_asn1_meths | + engine_method_pkey_meths | engine_method_pkey_asn1_meths | engine_method_ec. -type engine_ref() :: term(). @@ -681,7 +690,8 @@ engine_get_all_methods() -> PreCmds::[{unicode:chardata(), unicode:chardata()}], PostCmds::[{unicode:chardata(), unicode:chardata()}]) -> {ok, Engine::engine_ref()} | {error, Reason::term()}. -engine_load(EngineId, PreCmds, PostCmds) when is_list(PreCmds), is_list(PostCmds) -> +engine_load(EngineId, PreCmds, PostCmds) when is_list(PreCmds), + is_list(PostCmds) -> engine_load(EngineId, PreCmds, PostCmds, engine_get_all_methods()). %%---------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -698,28 +708,26 @@ engine_load(EngineId, PreCmds, PostCmds, EngineMethods) when is_list(PreCmds), ok = notsup_to_error(engine_load_dynamic_nif()), case notsup_to_error(engine_by_id_nif(ensure_bin_chardata(EngineId))) of {ok, Engine} -> - ok = engine_load_1(Engine, PreCmds, PostCmds, EngineMethods), - {ok, Engine}; + engine_load_1(Engine, PreCmds, PostCmds, EngineMethods); {error, Error1} -> {error, Error1} end catch - throw:Error2 -> - Error2 + throw:Error2 -> + Error2 end. engine_load_1(Engine, PreCmds, PostCmds, EngineMethods) -> try ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_ctrl_cmd_strings_nif(Engine, ensure_bin_cmds(PreCmds), 0)), - ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_add_nif(Engine)), ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_init_nif(Engine)), engine_load_2(Engine, PostCmds, EngineMethods), - ok + {ok, Engine} catch - throw:Error -> - %% The engine couldn't initialise, release the structural reference - ok = engine_free_nif(Engine), - throw(Error) + throw:Error -> + %% The engine couldn't initialise, release the structural reference + ok = engine_free_nif(Engine), + throw(Error) end. engine_load_2(Engine, PostCmds, EngineMethods) -> @@ -749,7 +757,6 @@ engine_unload(Engine, EngineMethods) -> try [ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_unregister_nif(Engine, engine_method_atom_to_int(Method))) || Method <- EngineMethods], - ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_remove_nif(Engine)), %% Release the functional reference from engine_init_nif ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_finish_nif(Engine)), %% Release the structural reference from engine_by_id_nif @@ -760,6 +767,41 @@ engine_unload(Engine, EngineMethods) -> end. %%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: engine_by_id/1 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +engine_by_id(EngineId) -> + try + notsup_to_error(engine_by_id_nif(ensure_bin_chardata(EngineId))) + catch + throw:Error -> + Error + end. + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: engine_add/1 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +engine_add(Engine) -> + notsup_to_error(engine_add_nif(Engine)). + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: engine_remove/1 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +engine_remove(Engine) -> + notsup_to_error(engine_remove_nif(Engine)). + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: engine_get_id/1 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +engine_get_id(Engine) -> + notsup_to_error(engine_get_id_nif(Engine)). + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: engine_get_name/1 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +engine_get_name(Engine) -> + notsup_to_error(engine_get_name_nif(Engine)). + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- %% Function: engine_list/0 %%---------------------------------------------------------------------- -spec engine_list() -> @@ -770,9 +812,9 @@ engine_list() -> []; {ok, Engine} -> case notsup_to_error(engine_get_id_nif(Engine)) of - {ok, <<>>} -> + <<>> -> engine_list(Engine, []); - {ok, EngineId} -> + EngineId -> engine_list(Engine, [EngineId]) end end. @@ -783,9 +825,9 @@ engine_list(Engine0, IdList) -> lists:reverse(IdList); {ok, Engine1} -> case notsup_to_error(engine_get_id_nif(Engine1)) of - {ok, <<>>} -> + <<>> -> engine_list(Engine1, IdList); - {ok, EngineId} -> + EngineId -> engine_list(Engine1, [EngineId |IdList]) end end. @@ -794,7 +836,7 @@ engine_list(Engine0, IdList) -> %% Function: engine_ctrl_cmd_string/3 %%---------------------------------------------------------------------- -spec engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine::term(), - CmdName::unicode:chardata(), + CmdName::unicode:chardata(), CmdArg::unicode:chardata()) -> ok | {error, Reason::term()}. engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine, CmdName, CmdArg) -> @@ -804,13 +846,13 @@ engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine, CmdName, CmdArg) -> %% Function: engine_ctrl_cmd_string/4 %%---------------------------------------------------------------------- -spec engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine::term(), - CmdName::unicode:chardata(), + CmdName::unicode:chardata(), CmdArg::unicode:chardata(), Optional::boolean()) -> ok | {error, Reason::term()}. engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine, CmdName, CmdArg, Optional) -> - case engine_ctrl_cmd_strings_nif(Engine, - ensure_bin_cmds([{CmdName, CmdArg}]), + case engine_ctrl_cmd_strings_nif(Engine, + ensure_bin_cmds([{CmdName, CmdArg}]), bool_to_int(Optional)) of ok -> ok; @@ -820,6 +862,82 @@ engine_ctrl_cmd_string(Engine, CmdName, CmdArg, Optional) -> {error, Error} end. +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: ensure_engine_loaded/2 +%% Special version of load that only uses dynamic engine to load +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +ensure_engine_loaded(EngineId, LibPath) -> + ensure_engine_loaded(EngineId, LibPath, engine_get_all_methods()). + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: ensure_engine_loaded/3 +%% Special version of load that only uses dynamic engine to load +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +ensure_engine_loaded(EngineId, LibPath, EngineMethods) -> + try + List = crypto:engine_list(), + case lists:member(EngineId, List) of + true -> + notsup_to_error(engine_by_id_nif(ensure_bin_chardata(EngineId))); + false -> + ok = notsup_to_error(engine_load_dynamic_nif()), + case notsup_to_error(engine_by_id_nif(ensure_bin_chardata(<<"dynamic">>))) of + {ok, Engine} -> + PreCommands = [{<<"SO_PATH">>, ensure_bin_chardata(LibPath)}, + {<<"ID">>, ensure_bin_chardata(EngineId)}, + <<"LOAD">>], + ensure_engine_loaded_1(Engine, PreCommands, EngineMethods); + {error, Error1} -> + {error, Error1} + end + end + catch + throw:Error2 -> + Error2 + end. + +ensure_engine_loaded_1(Engine, PreCmds, Methods) -> + try + ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_ctrl_cmd_strings_nif(Engine, ensure_bin_cmds(PreCmds), 0)), + ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_add_nif(Engine)), + ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_init_nif(Engine)), + ensure_engine_loaded_2(Engine, Methods), + {ok, Engine} + catch + throw:Error -> + %% The engine couldn't initialise, release the structural reference + ok = engine_free_nif(Engine), + throw(Error) + end. + +ensure_engine_loaded_2(Engine, Methods) -> + try + [ok = engine_nif_wrapper(engine_register_nif(Engine, engine_method_atom_to_int(Method))) || + Method <- Methods], + ok + catch + throw:Error -> + %% The engine registration failed, release the functional reference + ok = engine_finish_nif(Engine), + throw(Error) + end. +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: ensure_engine_unloaded/1 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +ensure_engine_unloaded(Engine) -> + ensure_engine_unloaded(Engine, engine_get_all_methods()). + +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Function: ensure_engine_unloaded/2 +%%---------------------------------------------------------------------- +ensure_engine_unloaded(Engine, EngineMethods) -> + case engine_remove(Engine) of + ok -> + engine_unload(Engine, EngineMethods); + {error, E} -> + {error, E} + end. + %%-------------------------------------------------------------------- %%% On load %%-------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -892,7 +1010,7 @@ path2bin(Path) when is_list(Path) -> max_bytes() -> ?MAX_BYTES_TO_NIF. -notsup_to_error(notsup) -> +notsup_to_error(notsup) -> erlang:error(notsup); notsup_to_error(Other) -> Other. @@ -1148,7 +1266,7 @@ privkey_to_pubkey(Alg, EngineMap) when Alg == rsa; Alg == dss; Alg == ecdsa -> error:notsup -> {error, notsup} end. - + privkey_to_pubkey_nif(_Alg, _EngineMap) -> ?nif_stub. @@ -1314,6 +1432,7 @@ engine_unregister_nif(_Engine, _EngineMethod) -> ?nif_stub. engine_get_first_nif() -> ?nif_stub. engine_get_next_nif(_Engine) -> ?nif_stub. engine_get_id_nif(_Engine) -> ?nif_stub. +engine_get_name_nif(_Engine) -> ?nif_stub. engine_get_all_methods_nif() -> ?nif_stub. %%-------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -1371,7 +1490,7 @@ get_test_engine() -> Type = erlang:system_info(system_architecture), LibDir = filename:join([code:priv_dir(crypto), "lib"]), ArchDir = filename:join([LibDir, Type]), - case filelib:is_dir(ArchDir) of + case filelib:is_dir(ArchDir) of true -> check_otp_test_engine(ArchDir); false -> check_otp_test_engine(LibDir) end. @@ -1389,4 +1508,3 @@ check_otp_test_engine(LibDir) -> {error, notexist} end end. - diff --git a/lib/crypto/test/engine_SUITE.erl b/lib/crypto/test/engine_SUITE.erl index f708d7272d..b083b30d70 100644 --- a/lib/crypto/test/engine_SUITE.erl +++ b/lib/crypto/test/engine_SUITE.erl @@ -39,6 +39,10 @@ all() -> get_all_possible_methods, engine_load_all_methods, engine_load_some_methods, + multiple_engine_load, + engine_list, + get_id_and_name, + engine_by_id, bad_arguments, unknown_engine, pre_command_fail_bad_value, @@ -46,6 +50,7 @@ all() -> failed_engine_init, ctrl_cmd_string, ctrl_cmd_string_optional, + ensure_load, {group, engine_stored_key} ]. @@ -97,7 +102,7 @@ init_per_group(engine_stored_key, Config) -> {error, notexist} -> {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; {error, notsup} -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"}; + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"}; {error, bad_engine_id} -> {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"}; Other -> @@ -132,11 +137,12 @@ get_all_possible_methods() -> get_all_possible_methods(Config) when is_list(Config) -> try List = crypto:engine_get_all_methods(), + true = erlang:is_list(List), ct:log("crypto:engine_get_all_methods() -> ~p\n", [List]), ok catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end. engine_load_all_methods()-> @@ -149,13 +155,12 @@ engine_load_all_methods(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {error, notexist} -> {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; {ok, Engine} -> - try + try Md5Hash1 = <<106,30,3,246,166,222,229,158,244,217,241,179,50,232,107,109>>, Md5Hash1 = crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic"), Md5Hash2 = <<0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15>>, case crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, - {<<"ID">>, <<"MD5">>}, <<"LOAD">>], []) of {ok, E} -> @@ -181,7 +186,7 @@ engine_load_all_methods(Config) when is_list(Config) -> end catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end end. @@ -195,21 +200,20 @@ engine_load_some_methods(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {error, notexist} -> {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; {ok, Engine} -> - try + try Md5Hash1 = <<106,30,3,246,166,222,229,158,244,217,241,179,50,232,107,109>>, Md5Hash1 = crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic"), Md5Hash2 = <<0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15>>, EngineMethods = crypto:engine_get_all_methods() -- - [engine_method_dh,engine_method_rand, + [engine_method_dh, engine_method_rand, engine_method_ciphers, engine_method_store, engine_method_pkey_meths, engine_method_pkey_asn1_meths], case crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, - {<<"ID">>, <<"MD5">>}, <<"LOAD">>], [], EngineMethods) of - {ok, E} -> + {ok, E} -> case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of Md5Hash1 -> ct:fail(fail_to_load_engine_still_original); @@ -232,7 +236,168 @@ engine_load_some_methods(Config) when is_list(Config) -> end catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end + end. + +multiple_engine_load()-> + [{doc, "Use a dummy md5 engine that does not implement md5" + "but rather returns a static binary to test that crypto:engine_load " + "functions works when called multiple times."}]. + +multiple_engine_load(Config) when is_list(Config) -> + case crypto:get_test_engine() of + {error, notexist} -> + {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; + {ok, Engine} -> + try + Md5Hash1 = <<106,30,3,246,166,222,229,158,244,217,241,179,50,232,107,109>>, + Md5Hash1 = crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic"), + Md5Hash2 = <<0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15>>, + case crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, + [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, + <<"LOAD">>], + []) of + {ok, E} -> + {ok, E1} = crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, + [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, + <<"LOAD">>], + []), + {ok, E2} = crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, + [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, + <<"LOAD">>], + []), + case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of + Md5Hash1 -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_still_original_engine); + Md5Hash2 -> + ok; + _ -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_engine) + end, + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E2), + case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of + Md5Hash1 -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_still_original_engine); + Md5Hash2 -> + ok; + _ -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_engine) + end, + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E), + case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of + Md5Hash1 -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_still_original_engine); + Md5Hash2 -> + ok; + _ -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_engine) + end, + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E1), + case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of + Md5Hash2 -> + ct:fail(fail_to_unload_still_test_engine); + Md5Hash1 -> + ok; + _ -> + ct:fail(fail_to_unload_engine) + end; + {error, bad_engine_id} -> + {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} + end + catch + error:notsup -> + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end + end. + +engine_list()-> + [{doc, "Test add and remove engine ID to the SSL internal engine list."}]. + +engine_list(Config) when is_list(Config) -> + case crypto:get_test_engine() of + {error, notexist} -> + {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; + {ok, Engine} -> + try + EngineList0 = crypto:engine_list(), + case crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, + [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, + <<"LOAD">>], + []) of + {ok, E} -> + EngineList0 = crypto:engine_list(), + ok = crypto:engine_add(E), + [<<"MD5">>] = lists:subtract(crypto:engine_list(), EngineList0), + ok = crypto:engine_remove(E), + EngineList0 = crypto:engine_list(), + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); + {error, bad_engine_id} -> + {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} + end + catch + error:notsup -> + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end + end. + +get_id_and_name()-> + [{doc, "Test fetching id and name from an engine."}]. + +get_id_and_name(Config) when is_list(Config) -> + case crypto:get_test_engine() of + {error, notexist} -> + {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; + {ok, Engine} -> + try + case crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, + [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, + <<"LOAD">>], + []) of + {ok, E} -> + <<"MD5">> = crypto:engine_get_id(E), + <<"MD5 test engine">> = crypto:engine_get_name(E), + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); + {error, bad_engine_id} -> + {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} + end + catch + error:notsup -> + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end + end. + +engine_by_id()-> + [{doc, "Test fetching a new reference the the engine when the" + "engine id is added to the SSL engine list."}]. + +engine_by_id(Config) when is_list(Config) -> + case crypto:get_test_engine() of + {error, notexist} -> + {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; + {ok, Engine} -> + try + case crypto:engine_load(<<"dynamic">>, + [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, + <<"LOAD">>], + []) of + {ok, E} -> + case crypto:engine_by_id(<<"MD5">>) of + {error,bad_engine_id} -> + ok; + {ok, _} -> + ct:fail(fail_engine_found) + end, + ok = crypto:engine_add(E), + {ok, _E1} = crypto:engine_by_id(<<"MD5">>), + ok = crypto:engine_remove(E), + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); + {error, bad_engine_id} -> + {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} + end + catch + error:notsup -> + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end end. @@ -246,7 +411,7 @@ bad_arguments(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {error, notexist} -> {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; {ok, Engine} -> - try + try try crypto:engine_load(fail_engine, [], []) catch @@ -276,7 +441,7 @@ bad_arguments(Config) when is_list(Config) -> end catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end end. @@ -289,7 +454,7 @@ unknown_engine(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ok catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end. pre_command_fail_bad_value() -> @@ -311,7 +476,7 @@ pre_command_fail_bad_value(Config) when is_list(Config) -> end catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end. pre_command_fail_bad_key() -> @@ -334,9 +499,9 @@ pre_command_fail_bad_key(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} end end - catch + catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end. failed_engine_init()-> @@ -352,18 +517,20 @@ failed_engine_init(Config) when is_list(Config) -> [{<<"SO_PATH">>, Engine}, {<<"ID">>, <<"MD5">>}], []) of - {error, add_engine_failed} -> + {error, engine_init_failed} -> ok; {error, bad_engine_id} -> {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} end end - catch + catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} end. +%%------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Test the optional flag in ctrl comands ctrl_cmd_string()-> [{doc, "Test that a not known optional ctrl comand do not fail"}]. ctrl_cmd_string(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -377,22 +544,22 @@ ctrl_cmd_string(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {<<"ID">>, <<"MD5">>}, <<"LOAD">>], []) of - {ok, E} -> + {ok, E} -> case crypto:engine_ctrl_cmd_string(E, <<"TEST">>, <<"17">>) of ok -> ct:fail(fail_ctrl_cmd_should_fail); - {error,ctrl_cmd_failed} -> + {error,ctrl_cmd_failed} -> ok end, - ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); {error, bad_engine_id} -> {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} end end - catch + catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} - end. + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end. ctrl_cmd_string_optional()-> [{doc, "Test that a not known optional ctrl comand do not fail"}]. @@ -407,22 +574,63 @@ ctrl_cmd_string_optional(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {<<"ID">>, <<"MD5">>}, <<"LOAD">>], []) of - {ok, E} -> + {ok, E} -> case crypto:engine_ctrl_cmd_string(E, <<"TEST">>, <<"17">>, true) of ok -> ok; - _ -> + _ -> ct:fail(fail_ctrl_cmd_string) end, - ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); + ok = crypto:engine_unload(E); {error, bad_engine_id} -> {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} end end - catch + catch error:notsup -> - {skip, "Engine not supported on this OpenSSL version"} - end. + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end. + +ensure_load()-> + [{doc, "Test the special ensure load function."}]. + +ensure_load(Config) when is_list(Config) -> + case crypto:get_test_engine() of + {error, notexist} -> + {skip, "OTP Test engine not found"}; + {ok, Engine} -> + try + Md5Hash1 = <<106,30,3,246,166,222,229,158,244,217,241,179,50,232,107,109>>, + Md5Hash1 = crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic"), + Md5Hash2 = <<0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15>>, + case crypto:ensure_engine_loaded(<<"MD5">>, Engine) of + {ok, E} -> + {ok, _E1} = crypto:ensure_engine_loaded(<<"MD5">>, Engine), + case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of + Md5Hash1 -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_still_original_engine); + Md5Hash2 -> + ok; + _ -> + ct:fail(fail_to_load_engine) + end, + ok = crypto:ensure_engine_unloaded(E), + case crypto:hash(md5, "Don't panic") of + Md5Hash2 -> + ct:fail(fail_to_unload_still_test_engine); + Md5Hash1 -> + ok; + _ -> + ct:fail(fail_to_unload_engine) + end; + {error, bad_engine_id} -> + {skip, "Dynamic Engine not supported"} + end + catch + error:notsup -> + {skip, "Engine not supported on this SSL version"} + end + end. %%%---------------------------------------------------------------- %%% Pub/priv key storage tests. Thoose are for testing the crypto.erl @@ -467,7 +675,7 @@ sign_verify_rsa_pwd_bad_pwd(Config) -> _ -> {fail, "PWD prot pubkey sign succeded with no pwd!"} catch error:badarg -> ok - end. + end. priv_encrypt_pub_decrypt_rsa(Config) -> Priv = #{engine => engine_ref(Config), @@ -540,7 +748,7 @@ get_pub_from_priv_key_rsa_pwd_no_pwd(Config) -> {skip, "RSA not supported"}; {error, Error} -> {fail, {wrong_error,Error}}; - Pub -> + Pub -> ct:log("rsa Pub = ~p",[Pub]), {fail, "PWD prot pubkey fetch succeded although no pwd!"} end. @@ -556,7 +764,7 @@ get_pub_from_priv_key_rsa_pwd_bad_pwd(Config) -> {skip, "RSA not supported"}; {error, Error} -> {fail, {wrong_error,Error}}; - Pub -> + Pub -> ct:log("rsa Pub = ~p",[Pub]), {fail, "PWD prot pubkey fetch succeded with bad pwd!"} end. @@ -590,7 +798,7 @@ get_pub_from_priv_key_ecdsa(Config) -> ct:log("ecdsa Pub = ~p",[Pub]), sign_verify(ecdsa, sha, Priv, Pub) end. - + %%%================================================================ %%% Help for engine_stored_pub_priv_keys* test cases %%% |