diff options
| -rw-r--r-- | lib/public_key/src/pubkey_crl.erl | 80 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | lib/public_key/test/pkits_SUITE.erl | 920 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | lib/public_key/test/public_key_SUITE.erl | 4 |
3 files changed, 417 insertions, 587 deletions
diff --git a/lib/public_key/src/pubkey_crl.erl b/lib/public_key/src/pubkey_crl.erl index 9d50288974..3e4c3c8b6d 100644 --- a/lib/public_key/src/pubkey_crl.erl +++ b/lib/public_key/src/pubkey_crl.erl @@ -22,10 +22,11 @@ -include("public_key.hrl"). -export([validate/7, init_revokation_state/0, fresh_crl/3, verify_crl_signature/4, - is_delta_crl/1, combines/2]). + is_delta_crl/1, combines/2, match_one/2]). --record(userstate, {dpcrls - }). +-record(userstate, {dpcrls, + idp + }). validate(OtpCert, OtherDPCRLs, DP, {DerCRL, CRL}, {DerDeltaCRL, DeltaCRL}, Options, RevokedState0) -> @@ -172,7 +173,7 @@ verify_mask_and_signatures(Revoked, DeltaRevoked, RevokedState, CRL, DerCRL, Del try verify_interim_reasons_mask(RevokedState), true = verify_crl_signatures(CRL, DerCRL, DeltaCRL, DerDeltaCRL, - TrustedOtpCert, Path, IssuerFun, OtherDPCRLs), + TrustedOtpCert, Path, IssuerFun, OtherDPCRLs, IDP), {valid, Revoked, DeltaRevoked, RevokedState#revoke_state{reasons_mask = ReasonsMask}, IDP} catch throw:_ -> @@ -183,7 +184,7 @@ verify_mask_and_signatures(Revoked, DeltaRevoked, RevokedState, CRL, DerCRL, Del verify_crl_signatures(CRL, DerCRL, DeltaCRL, DerDeltaCRL, TrustedOtpCert, Path, - IssuerFun, OtherDPCRLs) -> + IssuerFun, OtherDPCRLs, IDP) -> try VerifyFunAndState = {fun(_, {bad_cert, _} = Reason, _UserState) -> @@ -195,11 +196,11 @@ verify_crl_signatures(CRL, DerCRL, DeltaCRL, DerDeltaCRL, TrustedOtpCert, Path, (Cert, valid_peer, UserState) -> case verify_crl_keybit(Cert, cRLSign) of true -> - handle_signer(Cert, IssuerFun, UserState); + handle_crlsigner(Cert, IssuerFun, UserState); false -> {fail, crl_sign_bit_not_set} end - end, #userstate{dpcrls = OtherDPCRLs}}, + end, #userstate{dpcrls = OtherDPCRLs, idp = IDP}}, {ok, {{_,Key, KeyParams},_}} = public_key:pkix_path_validation(TrustedOtpCert, Path, @@ -211,17 +212,22 @@ verify_crl_signatures(CRL, DerCRL, DeltaCRL, DerDeltaCRL, TrustedOtpCert, Path, false end. -handle_signer(OtpCert, IssuerFun, UserState) -> +handle_crlsigner(OtpCert, IssuerFun, #userstate{idp = IDP} = UserState) -> case verify_crl_keybit(OtpCert, keyCertSign) of true -> {valid, UserState}; false -> - handle_crlsigner(OtpCert, IssuerFun, UserState) + case not is_indirect_crl(IDP) andalso not public_key:pkix_is_self_signed(OtpCert) of + true -> + validate_crl_signing_cert(OtpCert, IssuerFun, UserState); + false -> + {valid, UserState} + end end. -handle_crlsigner(_, _,#userstate{dpcrls = []} = UserState) -> +validate_crl_signing_cert(_, _,#userstate{dpcrls = []} = UserState) -> {valid, UserState}; -handle_crlsigner(OtpCert, IssuerFun, #userstate{dpcrls = CRLInfo} = UserState) -> +validate_crl_signing_cert(OtpCert, IssuerFun, #userstate{dpcrls = CRLInfo} = UserState) -> case public_key:pkix_crls_validate(OtpCert, CRLInfo, [{issuer_fun, IssuerFun}]) of valid -> {valid, UserState}; @@ -301,9 +307,9 @@ verify_issuer_and_scope(#'OTPCertificate'{tbsCertificate = TBSCert} = Cert, issuer_id(Cert, CRL); false -> %% otherwise verify that the CRL issuer matches the certificate issuer - verify_issuer_and_scope(Cert, DP#'DistributionPoint'{distributionPoint = - [TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.issuer], - cRLIssuer = asn1_NOVALUE}, + verify_issuer_and_scope(Cert, DP#'DistributionPoint'{ + distributionPoint = [TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.issuer], + cRLIssuer = asn1_NOVALUE}, IDP, CRL) end; verify_issuer_and_scope(#'OTPCertificate'{tbsCertificate = TBSCert}= Cert, @@ -332,13 +338,18 @@ verify_scope(_,_, undefined) -> ok; verify_scope(#'OTPCertificate'{tbsCertificate = TBSCert}, #'DistributionPoint'{cRLIssuer = DPIssuer} = DP, IDP) -> CertIssuer = TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.issuer, - Names = gen_names(DPIssuer), + Names = case gen_names(DPIssuer) of + [{directoryName, TNames}] -> + TNames; + Other -> + Other + end, DPName = dp_names(DP#'DistributionPoint'.distributionPoint, Names, CertIssuer), IDPName = dp_names(IDP#'IssuingDistributionPoint'.distributionPoint, Names, CertIssuer), verify_scope(DPName, IDPName, Names, TBSCert, IDP). verify_scope(asn1_NOVALUE, _, asn1_NOVALUE, _, _) -> - throw({bad_crl, scope_error}); + throw({bad_crl, scope_error1}); verify_scope(asn1_NOVALUE, IDPName, DPIssuerNames, TBSCert, IDP) -> verify_dp_name(IDPName, DPIssuerNames), verify_dp_bools(TBSCert, IDP); @@ -350,44 +361,43 @@ verify_scope(DPName, IDPName, _, TBSCert, IDP) -> dp_names(asn1_NOVALUE, _, _) -> asn1_NOVALUE; dp_names({fullName, Name}, _, _) -> - {fullName, gen_names(Name)}; + gen_names(Name); dp_names({nameRelativeToCRLIssuer, Fragment}, asn1_NOVALUE, {rdnSequence, RelativeDestinguistNames}) -> - {nameRelativeToCRLIssuer, [{directoryName, {rdnSequence, RelativeDestinguistNames ++ - lists:map(fun(AttrAndValue) -> - pubkey_cert_records:transform(AttrAndValue, decode) - end, Fragment)}}]}; + [{directoryName, {rdnSequence, RelativeDestinguistNames ++ + [lists:map(fun(AttrAndValue) -> + pubkey_cert_records:transform(AttrAndValue, decode) + end, Fragment)]}}]; dp_names({nameRelativeToCRLIssuer, Fragment},{rdnSequence, RelativeDestinguistNames}, _) -> - {nameRelativeToCRLIssuer, [{directoryName, {rdnSequence, RelativeDestinguistNames ++ - lists:map(fun(AttrAndValue) -> - pubkey_cert_records:transform(AttrAndValue, decode) - end, Fragment)}}]}; + [{directoryName, {rdnSequence, RelativeDestinguistNames ++ + [lists:map(fun(AttrAndValue) -> + pubkey_cert_records:transform(AttrAndValue, decode) + end, Fragment)]}}]; dp_names([{rdnSequence, _}] = Name0, _,_) -> [Name] = pubkey_cert_records:transform(Name0, decode), - {fullName, [{directoryName, Name}]}. + [{directoryName, Name}]. gen_names(asn1_NOVALUE) -> asn1_NOVALUE; gen_names([]) -> []; gen_names([{NameType, Name} | Rest]) -> - [{NameType, pubkey_cert_records:transform(Name, decode)} | gen_names(Rest)]. + [ {NameType, pubkey_cert_records:transform(Name, decode)} | gen_names(Rest)]. verify_dp_name(asn1_NOVALUE, _) -> ok; -verify_dp_name({Type, IDPNames}, {Type, DPorIssuerNames}) -> - case match_one(IDPNames, DPorIssuerNames) of + +verify_dp_name(IDPNames, DPorIssuerNames) -> + case match_one(DPorIssuerNames, IDPNames) of true -> ok; false -> throw({bad_crl, scope_error}) - end; -verify_dp_name(_,_) -> - throw({bad_crl, scope_error}). + end. match_one([], _) -> false; -match_one([{Type, Name} | RestIDP], DPorIssuerNames) -> - Candidates = [NameName || {NameType, NameName} <- DPorIssuerNames, NameType == Type], +match_one([{Type, Name} | Names], CandidateNames) -> + Candidates = [NameName || {NameType, NameName} <- CandidateNames, NameType == Type], case Candidates of [] -> false; @@ -395,7 +405,7 @@ match_one([{Type, Name} | RestIDP], DPorIssuerNames) -> true -> true; false -> - match_one(RestIDP, DPorIssuerNames) + match_one(Names, CandidateNames) end end. diff --git a/lib/public_key/test/pkits_SUITE.erl b/lib/public_key/test/pkits_SUITE.erl index 31725a09be..2b67460197 100644 --- a/lib/public_key/test/pkits_SUITE.erl +++ b/lib/public_key/test/pkits_SUITE.erl @@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ -module(pkits_SUITE). +%% Note: This directive should only be used in test suites. -compile(export_all). -include_lib("public_key/include/public_key.hrl"). @@ -46,7 +47,7 @@ crls, crl_paths, revoke_state}). -%% + suite() -> [{ct_hooks,[ts_install_cth]}]. @@ -63,6 +64,17 @@ all() -> {group, name_constraints}, {group, private_certificate_extensions}]. +init_per_suite(Config) -> + try crypto:start() of + ok -> + crypto_support_check(Config) + catch _:_ -> + {skip, "Crypto did not start"} + end. + +end_per_suite(_Config) -> + application:stop(crypto). + groups() -> [{signature_verification, [], [valid_rsa_signature, invalid_rsa_signature, valid_dsa_signature, @@ -119,18 +131,8 @@ init_per_testcase(_Func, Config) -> end_per_testcase(_Func, Config) -> Config. -init_per_suite(Config) -> - try crypto:start() of - ok -> - Config - catch _:_ -> - {skip, "Crypto did not start"} - end. -end_per_suite(_Config) -> - application:stop(crypto). - -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%--------------------------- signature_verification-------------------------------------------------- valid_rsa_signature(doc) -> ["Test rsa signatur verification"]; valid_rsa_signature(suite) -> @@ -160,9 +162,10 @@ invalid_dsa_signature(suite) -> []; invalid_dsa_signature(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.1.6", "Invalid DSA Signature Test6 EE",{bad_cert,invalid_signature}}]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- + +%%-----------------------------validity_periods------------------------------------------------ not_before_invalid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test valid periods"]; not_before_invalid(suite) -> []; not_before_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -170,7 +173,7 @@ not_before_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.2.2", "Invalid EE notBefore Date Test2 EE",{bad_cert, cert_expired}}]). not_before_valid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test valid periods"]; not_before_valid(suite) -> []; not_before_valid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -178,7 +181,7 @@ not_before_valid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.2.4", "Valid GeneralizedTime notBefore Date Test4 EE", ok}]). not_after_invalid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test valid periods"]; not_after_invalid(suite) -> []; not_after_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -187,14 +190,15 @@ not_after_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.2.7", "Invalid pre2000 UTC EE notAfter Date Test7 EE",{bad_cert, cert_expired}}]). not_after_valid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test valid periods"]; not_after_valid(suite) -> []; not_after_valid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.2.8", "Valid GeneralizedTime notAfter Date Test8 EE", ok}]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- + +%%----------------------------verifying_name_chaining------------------------------------------------- invalid_name_chain(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test name chaining"]; invalid_name_chain(suite) -> []; invalid_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -202,7 +206,7 @@ invalid_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.3.2", "Invalid Name Chaining Order Test2 EE", {bad_cert, invalid_issuer}}]). whitespace_name_chain(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test name chaining"]; whitespace_name_chain(suite) -> []; whitespace_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -210,21 +214,21 @@ whitespace_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.3.4", "Valid Name Chaining Whitespace Test4 EE", ok}]). capitalization_name_chain(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test name chaining"]; capitalization_name_chain(suite) -> []; capitalization_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.3.5", "Valid Name Chaining Capitalization Test5 EE",ok}]). uid_name_chain(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test name chaining"]; uid_name_chain(suite) -> []; uid_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.3.6", "Valid Name UIDs Test6 EE",ok}]). attrib_name_chain(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test name chaining"]; attrib_name_chain(suite) -> []; attrib_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -232,7 +236,7 @@ attrib_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.3.8", "Valid RFC3280 Optional Attribute Types Test8 EE", ok}]). string_name_chain(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test name chaining"]; string_name_chain(suite) -> []; string_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -240,10 +244,9 @@ string_name_chain(Config) when is_list(Config) -> %%{ "4.3.10", "Valid Rollover from PrintableString to UTF8String Test10 EE", ok}, { "4.3.11", "Valid UTF8String Case Insensitive Match Test11 EE", ok}]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- - +%%----------------------------verifying_paths_with_self_issued_certificates------------------------------------------------- basic_valid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test self issued certificates"]; basic_valid(suite) -> []; basic_valid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -253,7 +256,7 @@ basic_valid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). basic_invalid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test self issued certificates"]; basic_invalid(suite) -> []; basic_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -264,14 +267,14 @@ basic_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). crl_signing_valid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test self issued certificates"]; crl_signing_valid(suite) -> []; crl_signing_valid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.5.6", "Valid Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key Test6 EE", ok}]). crl_signing_invalid(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test self issued certificates"]; crl_signing_invalid(suite) -> []; crl_signing_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -281,9 +284,9 @@ crl_signing_invalid(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, invalid_key_usage}} ]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%-----------------------------basic_certificate_revocation_tests------------------------------------------------ missing_CRL(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; missing_CRL(suite) -> []; missing_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -291,7 +294,7 @@ missing_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> revocation_status_undetermined}}]). revoked_CA(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; revoked_CA(suite) -> []; revoked_CA(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -299,7 +302,7 @@ revoked_CA(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {revoked, keyCompromise}}}]). revoked_peer(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; revoked_peer(suite) -> []; revoked_peer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -307,14 +310,14 @@ revoked_peer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, {revoked, keyCompromise}}}]). invalid_CRL_signature(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; invalid_CRL_signature(suite) -> []; invalid_CRL_signature(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.4.4", "Invalid Bad CRL Signature Test4 EE", {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}}]). invalid_CRL_issuer(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; invalid_CRL_issuer(suite) -> []; invalid_CRL_issuer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -322,7 +325,7 @@ invalid_CRL_issuer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}}). invalid_CRL(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; invalid_CRL(suite) -> []; invalid_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -330,14 +333,14 @@ invalid_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}}]). valid_CRL(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; valid_CRL(suite) -> []; valid_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.4.7", "Valid Two CRLs Test7 EE", ok}]). unknown_CRL_extension(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; unknown_CRL_extension(suite) -> []; unknown_CRL_extension(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -349,7 +352,7 @@ unknown_CRL_extension(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}}]). old_CRL(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; old_CRL(suite) -> []; old_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -359,14 +362,14 @@ old_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}}]). fresh_CRL(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; fresh_CRL(suite) -> []; fresh_CRL(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.4.13", "Valid GeneralizedTime CRL nextUpdate Test13 EE", ok}]). valid_serial(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; valid_serial(suite) -> []; valid_serial(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -377,7 +380,7 @@ valid_serial(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). invalid_serial(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; invalid_serial(suite) -> []; invalid_serial(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -387,14 +390,14 @@ invalid_serial(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, {revoked, keyCompromise}}}]). valid_seperate_keys(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; valid_seperate_keys(suite) -> []; valid_seperate_keys(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.4.19", "Valid Separate Certificate and CRL Keys Test19 EE", ok}]). invalid_separate_keys(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test basic CRL handling"]; invalid_separate_keys(suite) -> []; invalid_separate_keys(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -403,9 +406,9 @@ invalid_separate_keys(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.4.21", "Invalid Separate Certificate and CRL Keys Test21 EE", {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}} ]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%----------------------------verifying_basic_constraints------------------------------------------------- missing_basic_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Basic constraint tests"]; missing_basic_constraints(suite) -> []; missing_basic_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -417,14 +420,14 @@ missing_basic_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, missing_basic_constraint}}]). valid_basic_constraint(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Basic constraint tests"]; valid_basic_constraint(suite) -> []; valid_basic_constraint(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{"4.6.4", "Valid basicConstraints Not Critical Test4 EE", ok}]). invalid_path_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Basic constraint tests"]; invalid_path_constraints(suite) -> []; invalid_path_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -438,7 +441,7 @@ invalid_path_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, max_path_length_reached}}]). valid_path_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Basic constraint tests"]; valid_path_constraints(suite) -> []; valid_path_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -449,9 +452,9 @@ valid_path_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.6.15", "Valid Self-Issued pathLenConstraint Test15 EE", ok}, { "4.6.17", "Valid Self-Issued pathLenConstraint Test17 EE", ok}]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%-----------------------------key_usage------------------------------------------------ invalid_key_usage(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Key usage tests"]; invalid_key_usage(suite) -> []; invalid_key_usage(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -466,41 +469,41 @@ invalid_key_usage(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). valid_key_usage(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Key usage tests"]; valid_key_usage(suite) -> []; valid_key_usage(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.7.3", "Valid keyUsage Not Critical Test3 EE", ok}]). %%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- -certificate_policies(doc) -> [""]; +certificate_policies(doc) -> ["Not supported yet"]; certificate_policies(suite) -> []; certificate_policies(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run(certificate_policies()). %%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- -require_explicit_policy(doc) -> [""]; +require_explicit_policy(doc) -> ["Not supported yet"]; require_explicit_policy(suite) -> []; require_explicit_policy(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run(require_explicit_policy()). %%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- -policy_mappings(doc) -> [""]; +policy_mappings(doc) -> ["Not supported yet"]; policy_mappings(suite) -> []; policy_mappings(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run(policy_mappings()). %%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- -inhibit_policy_mapping(doc) -> [""]; +inhibit_policy_mapping(doc) -> ["Not supported yet"]; inhibit_policy_mapping(suite) -> []; inhibit_policy_mapping(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run(inhibit_policy_mapping()). %%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- -inhibit_any_policy(doc) -> [""]; +inhibit_any_policy(doc) -> ["Not supported yet"]; inhibit_any_policy(suite) -> []; inhibit_any_policy(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run(inhibit_any_policy()). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%-------------------------------name_constraints---------------------------------------------- valid_DN_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; valid_DN_name_constraints(suite) -> []; valid_DN_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -514,7 +517,7 @@ valid_DN_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.13.19", "Valid DN nameConstraints Test19 EE", ok}]). invalid_DN_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; invalid_DN_name_constraints(suite) -> []; invalid_DN_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -533,7 +536,7 @@ invalid_DN_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, name_not_permitted}}]). valid_rfc822_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; valid_rfc822_name_constraints(suite) -> []; valid_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -541,9 +544,8 @@ valid_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.13.23", "Valid RFC822 nameConstraints Test23 EE", ok}, { "4.13.25", "Valid RFC822 nameConstraints Test25 EE", ok}]). - invalid_rfc822_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; invalid_rfc822_name_constraints(suite) -> []; invalid_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -555,14 +557,14 @@ invalid_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, name_not_permitted}}]). valid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; valid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(suite) -> []; valid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.13.27", "Valid DN and RFC822 nameConstraints Test27 EE", ok}]). invalid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; invalid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(suite) -> []; invalid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -572,7 +574,7 @@ invalid_DN_and_rfc822_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert, name_not_permitted}}]). valid_dns_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; valid_dns_name_constraints(suite) -> []; valid_dns_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -580,7 +582,7 @@ valid_dns_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.13.32", "Valid DNS nameConstraints Test32 EE", ok}]). invalid_dns_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; invalid_dns_name_constraints(suite) -> []; invalid_dns_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -589,7 +591,7 @@ invalid_dns_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.13.38", "Invalid DNS nameConstraints Test38 EE", {bad_cert, name_not_permitted}}]). valid_uri_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; valid_uri_name_constraints(suite) -> []; valid_uri_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -597,16 +599,16 @@ valid_uri_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.13.36", "Valid URI nameConstraints Test36 EE", ok}]). invalid_uri_name_constraints(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Name constraints tests"]; invalid_uri_name_constraints(suite) -> []; invalid_uri_name_constraints(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.13.35", "Invalid URI nameConstraints Test35 EE",{bad_cert, name_not_permitted}}, { "4.13.37", "Invalid URI nameConstraints Test37 EE",{bad_cert, name_not_permitted}}]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%------------------------------delta_crls----------------------------------------------- delta_without_crl(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Delta CRL tests"]; delta_without_crl(suite) -> []; delta_without_crl(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -614,9 +616,8 @@ delta_without_crl(Config) when is_list(Config) -> revocation_status_undetermined}}, {"4.15.10", "Invalid delta-CRL Test10 EE", {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}}]). - valid_delta_crls(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Delta CRL tests"]; valid_delta_crls(suite) -> []; valid_delta_crls(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -627,7 +628,7 @@ valid_delta_crls(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). invalid_delta_crls(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Delta CRL tests"]; invalid_delta_crls(suite) -> []; invalid_delta_crls(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -636,10 +637,9 @@ invalid_delta_crls(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.15.6", "Invalid delta-CRL Test6 EE", {bad_cert,{revoked, keyCompromise}}}, { "4.15.9", "Invalid delta-CRL Test9 EE", {bad_cert,{revoked, keyCompromise}}}]). -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- - +%%---------------------------distribution_points-------------------------------------------------- valid_distribution_points(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; valid_distribution_points(suite) -> []; valid_distribution_points(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -650,7 +650,7 @@ valid_distribution_points(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). valid_distribution_points_no_issuing_distribution_point(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; valid_distribution_points_no_issuing_distribution_point(suite) -> []; valid_distribution_points_no_issuing_distribution_point(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -658,7 +658,7 @@ valid_distribution_points_no_issuing_distribution_point(Config) when is_list(Con ]). invalid_distribution_points(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; invalid_distribution_points(suite) -> []; invalid_distribution_points(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -673,14 +673,14 @@ invalid_distribution_points(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). valid_only_contains(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; valid_only_contains(suite) -> []; valid_only_contains(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.14.13", "Valid only Contains CA Certs Test13 EE", ok}]). invalid_only_contains(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; invalid_only_contains(suite) -> []; invalid_only_contains(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -693,7 +693,7 @@ invalid_only_contains(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). valid_only_some_reasons(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; valid_only_some_reasons(suite) -> []; valid_only_some_reasons(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -702,7 +702,7 @@ valid_only_some_reasons(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). invalid_only_some_reasons(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; invalid_only_some_reasons(suite) -> []; invalid_only_some_reasons(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -719,7 +719,7 @@ invalid_only_some_reasons(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). valid_indirect_crl(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; valid_indirect_crl(suite) -> []; valid_indirect_crl(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -729,7 +729,7 @@ valid_indirect_crl(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). invalid_indirect_crl(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; invalid_indirect_crl(suite) -> []; invalid_indirect_crl(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -740,7 +740,7 @@ invalid_indirect_crl(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). valid_crl_issuer(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; valid_crl_issuer(suite) -> []; valid_crl_issuer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -750,7 +750,7 @@ valid_crl_issuer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> ]). invalid_crl_issuer(doc) -> - [""]; + ["CRL Distribution Point tests"]; invalid_crl_issuer(suite) -> []; invalid_crl_issuer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -762,21 +762,17 @@ invalid_crl_issuer(Config) when is_list(Config) -> { "4.14.35", "Invalid cRLIssuer Test35 EE", {bad_cert, revocation_status_undetermined}} ]). +%% Although this test is valid it has a circular dependency. As a result +%% an attempt is made to reursively checks a CRL path and rejected due to +%% a CRL path validation error. PKITS notes suggest this test does not +%% need to be run due to this issue. +%% { "4.14.30", "Valid cRLIssuer Test30", 54 } -%%distribution_points() -> - %%{ "4.14", "Distribution Points" }, -%% [ - %% Although this test is valid it has a circular dependency. As a result - %% an attempt is made to reursively checks a CRL path and rejected due to - %% a CRL path validation error. PKITS notes suggest this test does not - %% need to be run due to this issue. -%% { "4.14.30", "Valid cRLIssuer Test30", 54 }]. - -%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%%-------------------------------private_certificate_extensions---------------------------------------------- unknown_critical_extension(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test that a cert with an unknown critical extension is recjected"]; unknown_critical_extension(suite) -> []; unknown_critical_extension(Config) when is_list(Config) -> @@ -784,22 +780,22 @@ unknown_critical_extension(Config) when is_list(Config) -> {bad_cert,unknown_critical_extension}}]). unknown_not_critical_extension(doc) -> - [""]; + ["Test that a not critical unknown extension is ignored"]; unknown_not_critical_extension(suite) -> []; unknown_not_critical_extension(Config) when is_list(Config) -> run([{ "4.16.1", "Valid Unknown Not Critical Certificate Extension Test1 EE", ok}]). %%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% Internal functions +%%----------------------------------------------------------------------------- +%% run(Tests) -> [TA] = read_certs("Trust Anchor Root Certificate"), run(Tests, TA). run({Chap, Test, Result}, TA) -> CertChain = cas(Chap) ++ read_certs(Test), - lists:foreach(fun(C) -> - io:format("CERT: ~p~n", [public_key:pkix_decode_cert(C, otp)]) - end, CertChain), Options = path_validation_options(TA, Chap,Test), try public_key:pkix_path_validation(TA, CertChain, Options) of {Result, _} -> ok; @@ -840,6 +836,56 @@ path_validation_options(TA, Chap, Test) -> [{verify_fun, {Fun, []}}] end. +read_certs(Test) -> + File = cert_file(Test), + Ders = erl_make_certs:pem_to_der(File), + [Cert || {'Certificate', Cert, not_encrypted} <- Ders]. + +read_crls(Test) -> + File = crl_file(Test), + Ders = erl_make_certs:pem_to_der(File), + [CRL || {'CertificateList', CRL, not_encrypted} <- Ders]. + +cert_file(Test) -> + file(?CONV, lists:append(string:tokens(Test, " -")) ++ ".pem"). + +crl_file(Test) -> + file(?CRL, lists:append(string:tokens(Test, " -")) ++ ".pem"). + + +file(Sub,File) -> + TestDir = case get(datadir) of + undefined -> "./pkits_SUITE_data"; + Dir when is_list(Dir) -> + Dir + end, + AbsFile = filename:join([TestDir,Sub,File]), + case filelib:is_file(AbsFile) of + true -> ok; + false -> + ?error("Couldn't read data from ~p ~n",[AbsFile]) + end, + AbsFile. + +error(Format, Args, File0, Line) -> + File = filename:basename(File0), + Pid = group_leader(), + Pid ! {failed, File, Line}, + io:format(Pid, "~s(~p): ERROR"++Format, [File,Line|Args]). + +warning(Format, Args, File0, Line) -> + File = filename:basename(File0), + io:format("~s(~p): Warning "++Format, [File,Line|Args]). + +crypto_support_check(Config) -> + try crypto:sha256(<<"Test">>) of + _ -> + Config + catch error:notsup -> + crypto:stop(), + {skip, "To old version of openssl"} + end. + needs_crl_options("4.4" ++ _) -> true; needs_crl_options("4.5" ++ _) -> @@ -878,15 +924,10 @@ crl_options(_TA, Chap, _Test) -> Crls = [{DerCRL, public_key:der_decode('CertificateList', DerCRL)} || DerCRL <- DerCRLs], - test_server:format("START ~n", []), CRLInfo0 = crl_info(OtpCert, Crls, []), - test_server:format("END ~n", []), CRLInfo = lists:reverse(CRLInfo0), PathDb = crl_path_db(lists:reverse(Crls), Paths, []), - test_server:format("Pathdb: ~p~n", [PathDb]), - test_server:format("CRL INFO: ~p~n", [CRLInfo]), - Fun = fun(DP, CRLtoValidate, Id, PathDb0) -> trusted_cert_and_path(DP, CRLtoValidate, Id, PathDb0) end, @@ -919,194 +960,6 @@ crl_path_db([{_, CRL} |CRLs], [Path | Paths], Acc) -> end, Path)), crl_path_db(CRLs, Paths, [{CRL, CertPath}| Acc]). -crl_names("4.4.1") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.2") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Good CA CRL", "Revoked subCA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.3") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Good CA CRL", "Revoked subCA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.4") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Bad CRL Signature CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.5") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Bad CRL Issuer Name CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.6") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Wrong CRL CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.7") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Two CRLs CA Good CRL", "Two CRLs CA Bad CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.8") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Unknown CRL Entry Extension CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.4.9"; - Chap == "4.4.10"-> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Unknown CRL Extension CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.11") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Old CRL nextUpdate CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.12") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "pre2000 CRL nextUpdate CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.13") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "GeneralizedTime CRL nextUpdate CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.4.14"; - Chap == "4.4.15"-> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Negative Serial Number CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.4.16"; - Chap == "4.4.17"; - Chap == "4.4.18" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Long Serial Number CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap)when Chap == "4.4.19"; - Chap == "4.4.20" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CRL"]; -crl_names("4.4.21") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CA2 CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.1"; - Chap == "4.5.2"-> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Basic Self-Issued New Key CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.3"; - Chap == "4.5.4"; - Chap == "4.5.5" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Basic Self-Issued Old Key Self-Issued Cert CRL", - "Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.6"; - Chap == "4.5.7"; - Chap == "4.5.8" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert CRL", - "Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA CRL" - ]; -crl_names("4.7.4") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "keyUsage Critical cRLSign False CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.7.5") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "keyUsage Not Critical cRLSign False CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.1"; - Chap == "4.14.2"; - Chap == "4.14.3"; - Chap == "4.14.4" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "distributionPoint1 CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.5"; - Chap == "4.14.6"; - Chap == "4.14.7"; - Chap == "4.14.8"; - Chap == "4.14.9" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "distributionPoint2 CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.14.10") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "No issuingDistributionPoint CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.14.11") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlyContainsUserCerts CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.12"; - Chap == "4.14.13" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlyContainsCACerts CA CRL"]; -crl_names("4.14.14") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlyContainsAttributeCerts CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.15"; - Chap == "4.14.16" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlySomeReasons CA1 compromise CRL", - "onlySomeReasons CA1 other reasons CRL"]; -crl_names("4.14.17") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", - "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL1", "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL2"]; -crl_names("4.14.18") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", - "onlySomeReasons CA3 compromise CRL", "onlySomeReasons CA3 other reasons CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.19"; - Chap == "4.14.20"; - Chap == "4.14.21" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlySomeReasons CA4 compromise CRL", - "onlySomeReasons CA4 other reasons CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.22"; - Chap == "4.14.23"; - Chap == "4.14.24"; - Chap == "4.14.25"; - Chap == "4.14.26" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA1 CRL"]; -crl_names("4.14.27") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Good CA CRL"]; - -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.28"; - Chap == "4.14.29" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA3 CRL", "indirectCRL CA3 cRLIssuer CRL"]; -crl_names("4.14.30") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA4 cRLIssuer CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.31"; - Chap == "4.14.32"; - Chap == "4.14.33"; - Chap == "4.14.34"; - Chap == "4.14.35" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA5 CRL"]; -crl_names("4.15.1") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRLIndicator No Base CA CRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.15.2"; - Chap == "4.15.3"; - Chap == "4.15.4"; - Chap == "4.15.5"; - Chap == "4.15.6"; - Chap == "4.15.7" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRL CA1 CRL", "deltaCRL CA1 deltaCRL"]; -crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.15.8"; - Chap == "4.15.9" -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRL CA2 CRL", "deltaCRL CA2 deltaCRL"]; -crl_names("4.15.10") -> - ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRL CA3 CRL", "deltaCRL CA3 deltaCRL"]. - -crl_root_cert() -> - "Trust Anchor Root Certificate". - -crl_path("Trust Anchor Root CRL") -> - []; %% Signed directly by crl_root_cert -crl_path("Revoked subCA CRL") -> - ["Good CA Cert", "Revoked subCA Cert"]; -crl_path("indirectCRL CA3 cRLIssuer CRL") -> - ["indirectCRL CA3 Cert", "indirectCRL CA3 cRLIssuer Cert"]; -crl_path("Two CRLs CA Good CRL") -> - ["Two CRLs CA Cert"]; -crl_path("Two CRLs CA Bad CRL") -> - ["Two CRLs CA Cert"]; -crl_path("Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CRL") -> - ["Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CRL Signing Cert"]; -crl_path("Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CA2 CRL") -> - ["Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CA2 CRL Signing Cert"]; -crl_path("Basic Self-Issued Old Key Self-Issued Cert CRL") -> - ["Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA Cert"]; -crl_path("Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA CRL") -> - ["Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA Cert", "Basic Self-Issued Old Key NewWithOld CA Cert"]; - -crl_path("Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert CRL") -> - ["Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA Cert"]; -crl_path("Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA CRL") -> - ["Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA Cert", "Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert"]; - -crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA1 compromise CRL") -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA1 Cert"]; -crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA1 other reasons CRL") -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA1 Cert"]; -crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA3 other reasons CRL") -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA3 Cert"]; -crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA3 compromise CRL") -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA3 Cert"]; -crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA4 compromise CRL") -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA4 Cert"]; -crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA4 other reasons CRL") -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA4 Cert"]; -crl_path("Basic Self-Issued New Key CA CRL") -> - ["Basic Self-Issued New Key CA Cert"]; -crl_path("deltaCRL CA1 deltaCRL") -> - crl_path("deltaCRL CA2 CRL"); -crl_path("deltaCRL CA2 deltaCRL") -> - crl_path("deltaCRL CA2 CRL"); -crl_path("deltaCRL CA3 deltaCRL") -> - crl_path("deltaCRL CA3 CRL"); -crl_path(CRL) when CRL == "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL1"; - CRL == "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL2" -> - ["onlySomeReasons CA2 Cert"]; - -crl_path(CRL) -> - L = length(CRL), - Base = string:sub_string(CRL, 1, L -3), - [Base ++ "Cert"]. - -crls(CRLS) -> - lists:foldl(fun([], Acc) -> - Acc; - (CRLFile, Acc) -> - [CRL] = read_crls(CRLFile), - [CRL | Acc] - end, [], CRLS). crl_info(_, [], Acc) -> Acc; @@ -1119,45 +972,37 @@ crl_info(OtpCert, [{_, #'CertificateList'{tbsCertList = ExtList = pubkey_cert:extensions_list(CRLExtensions), DPs = case pubkey_cert:select_extension(?'id-ce-cRLDistributionPoints', Extensions) of #'Extension'{extnValue = Value} -> - TDPS = lists:foldl(fun(Point, Acc) -> - Dp = pubkey_cert_records:transform(Point, decode), - IDP = pubkey_cert:select_extension(?'id-ce-issuingDistributionPoint', Extensions), - case Dp#'DistributionPoint'.cRLIssuer of - asn1_NOVALUE -> - [Dp | Acc]; - DpCRLIssuer -> - CRLIssuer = dp_crlissuer_to_issuer(DpCRLIssuer), - CertIssuer = OtpTBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.issuer, - case pubkey_cert:is_issuer(CRLIssuer, CertIssuer) of - true -> - [Dp | Acc]; - false when (IDP =/= undefined) -> - Acc; - false -> - [Dp | Acc] - end - end - end, [], Value), - test_server:format("DPs: ~p ~n", [TDPS]), - TDPS; - _ -> - test_server:format("NO DP extension ~p ~n", [Extensions]), + lists:foldl(fun(Point, Acc0) -> + Dp = pubkey_cert_records:transform(Point, decode), + IDP = pubkey_cert:select_extension(?'id-ce-issuingDistributionPoint', + Extensions), + case Dp#'DistributionPoint'.cRLIssuer of + asn1_NOVALUE -> + [Dp | Acc0]; + DpCRLIssuer -> + CRLIssuer = dp_crlissuer_to_issuer(DpCRLIssuer), + CertIssuer = OtpTBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.issuer, + case pubkey_cert:is_issuer(CRLIssuer, CertIssuer) of + true -> + [Dp | Acc0]; + false when (IDP =/= undefined) -> + Acc0; + false -> + [Dp | Acc0] + end + end + end, [], Value); + _ -> case same_issuer(OtpCert, Issuer) of true -> [make_dp(ExtList, asn1_NOVALUE, Issuer)]; - false -> + false -> [make_dp(ExtList, Issuer, ignore)] end end, DPsCRLs = lists:map(fun(DP) -> {DP, CRL} end, DPs), crl_info(OtpCert, Rest, DPsCRLs ++ Acc). - -ignore_sign_test_when_building_path("Invalid Bad CRL Signature Test4") -> - true; -ignore_sign_test_when_building_path(_) -> - false. - same_issuer(OTPCert, Issuer) -> DecIssuer = pubkey_cert_records:transform(Issuer, decode), OTPTBSCert = OTPCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, @@ -1183,19 +1028,15 @@ make_dp(Extensions, Issuer0, DpInfo) -> mk_issuer_dp(asn1_NOVALUE, Issuer) -> {asn1_NOVALUE, {fullName, [{directoryName, Issuer}]}}; mk_issuer_dp(Issuer, _) -> - io:format("Issuer ~p~n", [Issuer]), {[{directoryName, Issuer}], asn1_NOVALUE}. update_crls(_, State) -> State. -trusted_cert_and_path(_, #'CertificateList'{tbsCertList = - #'TBSCertList'{issuer = Issuer}} = CRL, _, PathDb) -> +trusted_cert_and_path(_, #'CertificateList'{} = CRL, _, PathDb) -> [TrustedDERCert] = read_certs(crl_root_cert()), TrustedCert = public_key:pkix_decode_cert(TrustedDERCert, otp), - io:format("CRL~p ~n", [CRL]), - case lists:keysearch(CRL, 1, PathDb) of {_, {CRL, [ _| _] = Path}} -> {ok, TrustedCert, [TrustedDERCert | Path]}; @@ -1203,203 +1044,12 @@ trusted_cert_and_path(_, #'CertificateList'{tbsCertList = {ok, TrustedCert, [TrustedDERCert]} end. -%% trusted_cert_and_path(DP, CRL, Id, {Ignore, CertsList}) -> -%% case crl_issuer(crl_issuer_name(DP), CRL, Id, CertsList, CertsList, Ignore) of -%% {ok, IssuerCert, DerIssuerCert} -> -%% Certs = [{public_key:pkix_decode_cert(Cert, otp), Cert} || Cert <- CertsList], -%% CertChain = build_chain(Certs, Certs, IssuerCert, Ignore, [DerIssuerCert]), -%% {ok, public_key:pkix_decode_cert(hd(CertChain), otp), CertChain}; -%% Other -> -%% Other -%% end. - -crl_issuer_name(#'DistributionPoint'{cRLIssuer = asn1_NOVALUE}) -> - undefined; -crl_issuer_name(#'DistributionPoint'{cRLIssuer = [{directoryName, Issuer}]}) -> - pubkey_cert_records:transform(Issuer, decode). - -build_chain([],_, _, _,Acc) -> - Acc; - -build_chain([{First, DerFirst}|Certs], All, Cert, Ignore, Acc) -> - case public_key:pkix_is_self_signed(Cert) andalso is_test_root(Cert) of - true -> - Acc; - false -> - case public_key:pkix_is_issuer(Cert, First) - andalso check_extension_cert_signer(First) - andalso is_signer(First, Cert, Ignore) - of - true -> - build_chain(All, All, First, Ignore, [DerFirst | Acc]); - false -> - build_chain(Certs, All, Cert, Ignore, Acc) - end - end. - -is_signer(_,_, true) -> - true; -is_signer(Signer, #'OTPCertificate'{} = Cert,_) -> - TBSCert = Signer#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - PublicKeyInfo = TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.subjectPublicKeyInfo, - PublicKey = PublicKeyInfo#'OTPSubjectPublicKeyInfo'.subjectPublicKey, - AlgInfo = PublicKeyInfo#'OTPSubjectPublicKeyInfo'.algorithm, - PublicKeyParams = AlgInfo#'PublicKeyAlgorithm'.parameters, - try pubkey_cert:validate_signature(Cert, public_key:pkix_encode('OTPCertificate', - Cert, otp), - PublicKey, PublicKeyParams, true, ?DEFAULT_VERIFYFUN) of - true -> - true - catch - _:_ -> - false - end; -is_signer(Signer, #'CertificateList'{} = CRL, _) -> - TBSCert = Signer#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - PublicKeyInfo = TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.subjectPublicKeyInfo, - PublicKey = PublicKeyInfo#'OTPSubjectPublicKeyInfo'.subjectPublicKey, - AlgInfo = PublicKeyInfo#'OTPSubjectPublicKeyInfo'.algorithm, - PublicKeyParams = AlgInfo#'PublicKeyAlgorithm'.parameters, - pubkey_crl:verify_crl_signature(CRL, public_key:pkix_encode('CertificateList', - CRL, plain), - PublicKey, PublicKeyParams). - -is_test_root(OtpCert) -> - TBSCert = OtpCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - {rdnSequence, AtterList} = TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.issuer, - lists:member([{'AttributeTypeAndValue',{2,5,4,3},{printableString,"Trust Anchor"}}], - AtterList). - -check_extension_cert_signer(OtpCert) -> - TBSCert = OtpCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - Extensions = TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.extensions, - case pubkey_cert:select_extension(?'id-ce-keyUsage', Extensions) of - #'Extension'{extnValue = KeyUse} -> - lists:member(keyCertSign, KeyUse); - _ -> - true - end. - -check_extension_crl_signer(OtpCert) -> - TBSCert = OtpCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - Extensions = TBSCert#'OTPTBSCertificate'.extensions, - case pubkey_cert:select_extension(?'id-ce-keyUsage', Extensions) of - #'Extension'{extnValue = KeyUse} -> - lists:member(cRLSign, KeyUse); - _ -> - true - end. - -crl_issuer(undefined, CRL, issuer_not_found, _, CertsList, Ignore) -> - crl_issuer(CRL, CertsList, Ignore); - -crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, issuer_not_found, CertsList, CertsList, Ignore) -> - crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, IssuerName, CertsList, CertsList, Ignore); - -crl_issuer(undefined, CRL, Id, [Cert | Rest], All, false) -> - ErlCert = public_key:pkix_decode_cert(Cert, otp), - TBSCertificate = ErlCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - SerialNumber = TBSCertificate#'OTPTBSCertificate'.serialNumber, - Issuer = public_key:pkix_normalize_name( - TBSCertificate#'OTPTBSCertificate'.subject), - Bool = is_signer(ErlCert, CRL, false), - case {SerialNumber, Issuer} of - Id when Bool == true -> - {ok, ErlCert, Cert}; - _ -> - crl_issuer(undefined, CRL, Id, Rest, All, false) - end; - -crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, Id, [Cert | Rest], All, false) -> - ErlCert = public_key:pkix_decode_cert(Cert, otp), - TBSCertificate = ErlCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - SerialNumber = TBSCertificate#'OTPTBSCertificate'.serialNumber, - %Issuer = public_key:pkix_normalize_name( - % TBSCertificate#'OTPTBSCertificate'.subject), - Bool = is_signer(ErlCert, CRL, false), - case {SerialNumber, IssuerName} of - Id when Bool == true -> - {ok, ErlCert, Cert}; - {_, IssuerName} when Bool == true -> - {ok, ErlCert, Cert}; - _ -> - crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, Id, Rest, All, false) - end; - -crl_issuer(undefined, CRL, _, [], CertsList, Ignore) -> - crl_issuer(CRL, CertsList, Ignore); -crl_issuer(CRLName, CRL, _, [], CertsList, Ignore) -> - crl_issuer(CRLName, CRL, CertsList, Ignore). - - -crl_issuer(_, [],_) -> - {error, issuer_not_found}; -crl_issuer(CRL, [Cert | Rest], Ignore) -> - ErlCert = public_key:pkix_decode_cert(Cert, otp), - case public_key:pkix_is_issuer(CRL, ErlCert) andalso - check_extension_crl_signer(ErlCert) andalso - is_signer(ErlCert, CRL, Ignore) - of - true -> - {ok, ErlCert,Cert}; - false -> - crl_issuer(CRL, Rest, Ignore) - end. - -crl_issuer(_,_, [],_) -> - {error, issuer_not_found}; -crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, [Cert | Rest], Ignore) -> - ErlCert = public_key:pkix_decode_cert(Cert, otp), - TBSCertificate = ErlCert#'OTPCertificate'.tbsCertificate, - Issuer = public_key:pkix_normalize_name( - TBSCertificate#'OTPTBSCertificate'.subject), - - case - public_key:pkix_is_issuer(CRL, ErlCert) andalso - check_extension_crl_signer(ErlCert) andalso - is_signer(ErlCert, CRL, Ignore) - of - true -> - case pubkey_cert:is_issuer(Issuer, IssuerName) of - true -> - {ok, ErlCert,Cert}; - false -> - crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, Rest, Ignore) - end; - false -> - crl_issuer(IssuerName, CRL, Rest, Ignore) - end. - -read_certs(Test) -> - File = cert_file(Test), - Ders = erl_make_certs:pem_to_der(File), - [Cert || {'Certificate', Cert, not_encrypted} <- Ders]. - -read_crls(Test) -> - File = crl_file(Test), - Ders = erl_make_certs:pem_to_der(File), - [CRL || {'CertificateList', CRL, not_encrypted} <- Ders]. - -cert_file(Test) -> - file(?CONV, lists:append(string:tokens(Test, " -")) ++ ".pem"). - -crl_file(Test) -> - file(?CRL, lists:append(string:tokens(Test, " -")) ++ ".pem"). +dp_crlissuer_to_issuer(DPCRLIssuer) -> + [{directoryName, Issuer}] = pubkey_cert_records:transform(DPCRLIssuer, decode), + Issuer. -file(Sub,File) -> - TestDir = case get(datadir) of - undefined -> "./pkits_SUITE_data"; - Dir when is_list(Dir) -> - Dir - end, - AbsFile = filename:join([TestDir,Sub,File]), - case filelib:is_file(AbsFile) of - true -> ok; - false -> - ?error("Couldn't read data from ~p ~n",[AbsFile]) - end, - AbsFile. +%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% CA mappings %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% cas(Chap) -> CAS = intermidiate_cas(Chap), @@ -1732,7 +1382,7 @@ intermidiate_cas(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.24"; Chap == "4.14.25"; Chap == "4.14.26" -> ["indirectCRL CA2 Cert"]; -%%FOO + intermidiate_cas(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.27" -> ["indirectCRL CA2 Cert"]; @@ -1773,23 +1423,207 @@ intermidiate_cas(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.6"; intermidiate_cas(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.8" -> ["Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert"]. -error(Format, Args, File0, Line) -> - File = filename:basename(File0), - Pid = group_leader(), - Pid ! {failed, File, Line}, - io:format(Pid, "~s(~p): ERROR"++Format, [File,Line|Args]). -warning(Format, Args, File0, Line) -> - File = filename:basename(File0), - io:format("~s(~p): Warning "++Format, [File,Line|Args]). +%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% CRL mappings %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% +crl_names("4.4.1") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.2") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Good CA CRL", "Revoked subCA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.3") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Good CA CRL", "Revoked subCA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.4") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Bad CRL Signature CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.5") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Bad CRL Issuer Name CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.6") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Wrong CRL CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.7") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Two CRLs CA Good CRL", "Two CRLs CA Bad CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.8") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Unknown CRL Entry Extension CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.4.9"; + Chap == "4.4.10"-> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Unknown CRL Extension CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.11") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Old CRL nextUpdate CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.12") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "pre2000 CRL nextUpdate CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.13") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "GeneralizedTime CRL nextUpdate CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.4.14"; + Chap == "4.4.15"-> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Negative Serial Number CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.4.16"; + Chap == "4.4.17"; + Chap == "4.4.18" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Long Serial Number CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap)when Chap == "4.4.19"; + Chap == "4.4.20" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CRL"]; +crl_names("4.4.21") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CA2 CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.1"; + Chap == "4.5.2"-> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Basic Self-Issued New Key CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.3"; + Chap == "4.5.4"; + Chap == "4.5.5" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Basic Self-Issued Old Key Self-Issued Cert CRL", + "Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.5.6"; + Chap == "4.5.7"; + Chap == "4.5.8" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert CRL", + "Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA CRL" + ]; +crl_names("4.7.4") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "keyUsage Critical cRLSign False CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.7.5") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "keyUsage Not Critical cRLSign False CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.1"; + Chap == "4.14.2"; + Chap == "4.14.3"; + Chap == "4.14.4" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "distributionPoint1 CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.5"; + Chap == "4.14.6"; + Chap == "4.14.7"; + Chap == "4.14.8"; + Chap == "4.14.9" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "distributionPoint2 CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.14.10") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "No issuingDistributionPoint CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.14.11") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlyContainsUserCerts CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.12"; + Chap == "4.14.13" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlyContainsCACerts CA CRL"]; +crl_names("4.14.14") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlyContainsAttributeCerts CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.15"; + Chap == "4.14.16" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlySomeReasons CA1 compromise CRL", + "onlySomeReasons CA1 other reasons CRL"]; +crl_names("4.14.17") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", + "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL1", "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL2"]; +crl_names("4.14.18") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", + "onlySomeReasons CA3 compromise CRL", "onlySomeReasons CA3 other reasons CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.19"; + Chap == "4.14.20"; + Chap == "4.14.21" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "onlySomeReasons CA4 compromise CRL", + "onlySomeReasons CA4 other reasons CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.22"; + Chap == "4.14.23"; + Chap == "4.14.24"; + Chap == "4.14.25"; + Chap == "4.14.26" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA1 CRL"]; +crl_names("4.14.27") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "Good CA CRL"]; + +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.28"; + Chap == "4.14.29" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA3 CRL", "indirectCRL CA3 cRLIssuer CRL"]; +crl_names("4.14.30") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA4 cRLIssuer CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.14.31"; + Chap == "4.14.32"; + Chap == "4.14.33"; + Chap == "4.14.34"; + Chap == "4.14.35" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "indirectCRL CA5 CRL"]; +crl_names("4.15.1") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRLIndicator No Base CA CRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.15.2"; + Chap == "4.15.3"; + Chap == "4.15.4"; + Chap == "4.15.5"; + Chap == "4.15.6"; + Chap == "4.15.7" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRL CA1 CRL", "deltaCRL CA1 deltaCRL"]; +crl_names(Chap) when Chap == "4.15.8"; + Chap == "4.15.9" -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRL CA2 CRL", "deltaCRL CA2 deltaCRL"]; +crl_names("4.15.10") -> + ["Trust Anchor Root CRL", "deltaCRL CA3 CRL", "deltaCRL CA3 deltaCRL"]. + +crl_root_cert() -> + "Trust Anchor Root Certificate". + +crl_path("Trust Anchor Root CRL") -> + []; %% Signed directly by crl_root_cert +crl_path("Revoked subCA CRL") -> + ["Good CA Cert", "Revoked subCA Cert"]; +crl_path("indirectCRL CA3 cRLIssuer CRL") -> + ["indirectCRL CA3 Cert", "indirectCRL CA3 cRLIssuer Cert"]; +crl_path("Two CRLs CA Good CRL") -> + ["Two CRLs CA Cert"]; +crl_path("Two CRLs CA Bad CRL") -> + ["Two CRLs CA Cert"]; +crl_path("Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CRL") -> + ["Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CRL Signing Cert"]; +crl_path("Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CA2 CRL") -> + ["Separate Certificate and CRL Keys CA2 CRL Signing Cert"]; +crl_path("Basic Self-Issued Old Key Self-Issued Cert CRL") -> + ["Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA Cert"]; +crl_path("Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA CRL") -> + ["Basic Self-Issued Old Key CA Cert", "Basic Self-Issued Old Key NewWithOld CA Cert"]; + +crl_path("Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert CRL") -> + ["Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA Cert"]; +crl_path("Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA CRL") -> + ["Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CA Cert", "Basic Self-Issued CRL Signing Key CRL Cert"]; + +crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA1 compromise CRL") -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA1 Cert"]; +crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA1 other reasons CRL") -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA1 Cert"]; +crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA3 other reasons CRL") -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA3 Cert"]; +crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA3 compromise CRL") -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA3 Cert"]; +crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA4 compromise CRL") -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA4 Cert"]; +crl_path("onlySomeReasons CA4 other reasons CRL") -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA4 Cert"]; +crl_path("Basic Self-Issued New Key CA CRL") -> + ["Basic Self-Issued New Key CA Cert"]; +crl_path("deltaCRL CA1 deltaCRL") -> + crl_path("deltaCRL CA2 CRL"); +crl_path("deltaCRL CA2 deltaCRL") -> + crl_path("deltaCRL CA2 CRL"); +crl_path("deltaCRL CA3 deltaCRL") -> + crl_path("deltaCRL CA3 CRL"); +crl_path(CRL) when CRL == "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL1"; + CRL == "onlySomeReasons CA2 CRL2" -> + ["onlySomeReasons CA2 Cert"]; + +crl_path(CRL) -> + L = length(CRL), + Base = string:sub_string(CRL, 1, L -3), + [Base ++ "Cert"]. + +crls(CRLS) -> + lists:foldl(fun([], Acc) -> + Acc; + (CRLFile, Acc) -> + [CRL] = read_crls(CRLFile), + [CRL | Acc] + end, [], CRLS). + + +%% TODO: If we implement policy support %% Certificate policy tests need special handling. They can have several %% sub tests and we need to check the outputs are correct. certificate_policies() -> %%{ "4.8", "Certificate Policies" }, [{"4.8.1.1", "All Certificates Same Policy Test1", "-policy anyPolicy -explicit_policy", "True", ?NIST1, ?NIST1, 0}, - {"4.8.1.2", "All Certificates Same Policy Test1", "-policy ?NIST1 -explicit_policy", "True", ?NIST1, ?NIST1, 0}, + {"4.8.1.2", "All Certificates Same Policy Test1", "-policy ?NIST1BasicSelfIssuedCRLSigningKeyCACert.pem -explicit_policy", "True", ?NIST1, ?NIST1, 0}, {"4.8.1.3", "All Certificates Same Policy Test1", "-policy ?NIST2 -explicit_policy", "True", ?NIST1, "<empty>", 43}, {"4.8.1.4", "All Certificates Same Policy Test1", "-policy ?NIST1 -policy ?NIST2 -explicit_policy", "True", ?NIST1, ?NIST1, 0}, {"4.8.2.1", "All Certificates No Policies Test2", "-policy anyPolicy", "False", "<empty>", "<empty>", 0}, @@ -1889,17 +1723,3 @@ inhibit_any_policy() -> {"4.12.8", "Invalid Self-Issued inhibitAnyPolicy Test8", 43 }, {"4.12.9", "Valid Self-Issued inhibitAnyPolicy Test9", ok}, {"4.12.10", "Invalid Self-Issued inhibitAnyPolicy Test10", 43 }]. - -crypto_support_check(Config) -> - crypto:start(), - try crypto:sha256(<<"Test">>) of - _ -> - Config - catch error:notsup -> - crypto:stop(), - {skip, "To old version of openssl"} - end. - -dp_crlissuer_to_issuer(DPCRLIssuer) -> - [{directoryName, Issuer}] = pubkey_cert_records:transform(DPCRLIssuer, decode), - Issuer. diff --git a/lib/public_key/test/public_key_SUITE.erl b/lib/public_key/test/public_key_SUITE.erl index 608cc91706..557092b690 100644 --- a/lib/public_key/test/public_key_SUITE.erl +++ b/lib/public_key/test/public_key_SUITE.erl @@ -691,8 +691,8 @@ pkix(Config) when is_list(Config) -> [[{'AttributeTypeAndValue', {2,5,4,3},{printableString,"ERLANGCA"}}], [{'AttributeTypeAndValue', {2,5,4,3},{printableString," erlang ca "}}]]}, VerifyStr = {rdnSequence, - [[{'AttributeTypeAndValue', {2,5,4,3},{printableString,"erlang ca"}}], - [{'AttributeTypeAndValue', {2,5,4,3},{printableString,"erlangca"}}]]}, + [[{'AttributeTypeAndValue', {2,5,4,3},{printableString,"erlangca"}}], + [{'AttributeTypeAndValue', {2,5,4,3},{printableString,"erlang ca"}}]]}, VerifyStr = public_key:pkix_normalize_name(TestStr), ok. |